Links and reputation · guide 3 of 3
Toxic links and disavow: what to do when a report says your site is in danger
A tool flagged hundreds of “toxic” backlinks. Here is what Google actually says about spammy links, the narrow cases where the disavow tool helps, and how to use it without harming your site.
23 min readUpdated 9 Nov 2026
- 9 questions to test yourself
- 1 calculator
- 7-item checklist
On this page10 sections
A report says your links are toxic. Should you panic?
It usually arrives as a red number: “Toxic score 62%”, “214 toxic domains”, often with an offer to clean them up for a monthly fee. The links come from sites you have never heard of, in languages you do not speak. It feels like someone is attacking your business.
By the end of this guide you will know, for your own site, whether you need to do anything at all. For most small businesses the honest answer is no. For a few there is a real job to do, and it needs care, because the tool that fixes it can also break things.
On the way you will get a check that takes about a minute and settles the question for most owners (fourth section), and you will meet the link a panicked clean-up most often throws away: often one of the best links a small business has.
First, a quick test of your instincts.
Quick quiz
A bakery's audit flags 180 “toxic” links from foreign directory and scraper sites. The owner never bought links and has no message in Search Console. What does Google's own guidance suggest?
Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.
Google ignores most spam links: what that really means
Every site that has been online for a while collects junk links. Scrapers copy your pages and keep your links in them. Auto-generated “site value” and “whois” pages list your domain. Spam directories add you to pad their pages. None of this needs your permission, and almost every established site has some.
Google knows this. Its documentation on the disavow tool says Google can usually assess which links to trust without additional guidance, and that most sites will not need the tool. When Google announced its December 2022 link spam update, it explained that it uses SpamBrain, its spam-detection system, to neutralise the effect of unnatural links. Neutralise means they count for nothing, not that they count against you.
So a spammy link usually sits in one of two states: Google ignores it, or, rarely, someone has built enough of them deliberately that Google takes action. The second case almost always involves links that were paid for, swapped or mass-produced to manipulate rankings.
Myth or fact?
Five things owners believe about bad links
1.A competitor can easily sink your rankings by pointing spam links at your site.
2.If you once paid for links to rank, a disavow file can be the right tool.
3.Disavowing a link deletes it from the internet.
4.Disavowing good links by mistake can hurt your site.
5.You should check and update your disavow file every month as routine maintenance.
Read the report like an expert: what the flagged links usually are
Open the list of flagged links and you will usually find the same few kinds over and over. Learning to recognise them takes ten minutes and saves most owners from doing anything drastic.
Try each one below: decide whether you would ignore it or act on it, then flip the card.
Test yourself
Think of your answer, then flip the card.0 of 6 flipped
Try the numbers
Apply the question to your own report
Domains to leave alone
195 domains
Share of the report that is your job
3%
Removal work, roughly
about 1.7 hours
Your own estimate from your own count, not a diagnosis. If you are unsure about a domain, count it as built for now and check it later. If the share that is your job is close to zero, the next section's one-minute check will probably confirm you can stop here; if it is not, the hours tell you whether to do the removals yourself or ask for help.
When disavow is actually the right move
Google's documentation gives two conditions, and it says you should consider disavowing only when both are true. First, you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links pointing to your site. Second, those links have caused a manual action, or are likely to cause one.
Here is the one-minute check promised at the start. A manual action is a penalty applied by a person at Google, not by an algorithm. In Google Search Console, open Security and manual actions, then Manual actions. If it says “No issues detected”, you do not have one. If it says “Unnatural links to your site”, Google has seen a pattern of links it considers manipulative.
Never opened Search Console? The Search Console tour guide gets you signed in and to this page in a few minutes. If the page does list an action, keep reading here, then use the Google penalties guide to see how manual actions differ from algorithm drops.
“Likely to cause one” is the grey area. In practice it covers owners who know links were bought or built in bulk, by them or by a previous agency, and who want to clean up before anyone at Google looks.
Score yourself
Do you need to disavow? Answer honestly
Search Console shows a manual action for unnatural links to your site, now or in the past.
You, or an agency or freelancer you hired, paid for links or bought a backlink package.
Someone ran link exchanges, private blog networks or mass guest posts for you.
Many flagged links use the same keyword-rich anchor text rather than your business name or web address.
You tried asking for removal and the links are still there.
0 of 5 answered. Answer them all to see your result.
Remove, disavow or ignore: the three options side by side
Disavowing is not the only response, and Google's guidance treats it as the last one. Its manual actions help describes removing unnatural links, or getting them marked nofollow, as the first thing to try, and disavowing the ones you cannot remove.
Side by side
| Question | Ignore | Remove or nofollow | Disavow |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Spam you never built | Paid or built links you can trace | Built links you cannot remove |
| What happens to the link | Nothing; Google decides | It disappears, or is marked so it passes no credit | It stays; Google is asked not to count it |
| Effort | None | High: emails, follow-ups, records | Medium: one carefully checked file |
| Risk if you get it wrong | Low for unbuilt spam | Low | Real: good links stop helping |
| Helps a reconsideration request | Not needed | Yes, strongly | Yes, alongside removal |
How to clean up, in the right order
If your self-score put you in the last band, the order of the work matters. Doing it out of order is how owners end up disavowing their best links or sending a reconsideration request Google rejects.
Put it in order
Put the clean-up steps in the order you would do them
Use the arrows to move each item, then check.
- Disavow the ones still live after a fair wait
- Export your links from Search Console
- Mark the links that were built or paid for
- Ask those sites to remove the links, and keep a record
- Send a reconsideration request if there is a manual action
To see this order applied to a whole link profile, read the Mapletrack Outfitters study on our Case studies page. It is an illustrative example, an invented canoe outfitter with modelled figures, whose only links came from a paid directory network. Removal requests went to every directory; only the ones that never answered went into a disavow file, and two genuine regional listings were kept and corrected rather than thrown out.
If your last step is a reconsideration request, the Google penalties guide covers what Google expects it to contain. The short version: say what happened, show what you removed and what you disavowed, and keep the records from step three.
Building the disavow file without throwing away good links
If, after the removal requests and a fair wait, some built links are still live, this is where the disavow file comes in. It is a short plain text file, but one detail of how Google handles it catches out even experienced agencies. Test yourself first.
Quick quiz
Last year an agency uploaded a disavow file with 40 domains. Today you upload a new file listing 3 newly found domains. What happens to the 40?
Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.
Step by step
Building and uploading a disavow file
Step 1 of 5
Get your links from Search Console
In Search Console, open Links, then use Export external links to download the latest links. Google's own export is a better starting point than a third-party list, because it shows links Google has actually found.
Before and after
The same clean-up, two disavow files
Panic file
domain:chamber-of-commerce-example.org
domain:localnews-example.com
domain:website-worth-example.net
… plus 210 more domains copied straight from a tool's toxic list
Careful file
Only what was built
# Links bought in a 2023 package from an SEO freelancer
# Removal requested 3 March, no reply by 31 March
domain:guestpost-farm-example.com
domain:pbn-network-example.net
https://forum-example.org/profile/12345
- This is an illustrative example: the domains are made up.
- Here is the link we promised to come back to. The panic file disavows a real chamber of commerce and a local news site, because a tool gave them a low score. Real local organisations that link to you because you exist are among the hardest links for a small business to earn, and the easiest for a raw toxic list to throw away.
- The careful file names only links that were built, and its comments record where they came from and what removal was tried. That record helps with a reconsideration request and with anyone who edits the file after you.
The risks nobody mentions in the sales email
Disavow has a short list of real costs, and they are worth knowing before you upload anything.
- Good links stop counting. If a tool's list includes your local press, suppliers or associations, disavowing them removes some of your strongest signals. Google's help page warns that incorrect use can harm your performance in Search.
- It does not fix a drop with another cause. If traffic fell after a core update or a site change, a disavow file is very unlikely to bring it back. Check what changed first; the traffic drop guide walks through it.
- Results are slow and invisible. No report shows what a disavow changed, so a promised ranking jump from one is a promise nobody can verify.
- It can become a paid habit. Monthly “toxic link removal” retainers are a common upsell. If you never built links, there is usually nothing to remove.
What would you do?
The cold email
This is an illustrative example. A florist with no manual action in Search Console gets an email: “Our scan found 340 toxic backlinks putting your rankings at risk. For €290 a month we will monitor and disavow them for you.” Traffic has been steady for a year. The florist has never paid for links.
What is the most sensible response?
A scary scan followed by a monthly fee is a pattern worth recognising wherever it turns up. The SEO scams guide collects the other red flags in pitches like this one, and how to check each claim yourself before you pay anything.
If you already have a disavow file, or got it wrong
Many owners inherit a file from a previous agency and have no idea what is in it. It is worth one look. Download the current list from the disavow tool and read it. If you recognise good sites in it, such as local papers, partners or associations, remove those lines and upload the corrected complete file.
If the whole file was a panic upload and you never built links, you can remove the list in the disavow tool. Google treats those links normally again as it recrawls them, which takes time, so do not expect an overnight change.
Questions people ask
Will disavowing links improve my rankings?
Only in the narrow case where built links were holding you back, usually through a manual action. For everyone else, Google is already ignoring the spam, so there is nothing to gain. Nobody can promise a ranking change from a disavow file.
Should I disavow links from sites in other countries or languages?
Not because of the country or language alone. A foreign-language link you did not build is usually background noise. What matters is whether it was created to manipulate rankings.
How do I know if someone is attacking my site with spam links?
Look for a sudden, large pattern of links with identical keyword anchor text, then check whether Search Console shows a manual action. Google says it works to prevent this kind of harm, and in most cases the links are simply neutralised. If you see a manual action you did not cause, document it and explain it in your reconsideration request.
Do nofollow links need disavowing?
No. A link marked nofollow, sponsored or ugc already tells Google not to treat it as an endorsement in the normal way. That is also the fix Google asks for when you pay for a link legitimately, such as a sponsorship: the site should mark it sponsored or nofollow.
My manual action was lifted. Can I now delete the file?
Keep it as long as the built links are still live. Cancelling the file would tell Google it may count those links again, and they are what caused the manual action in the first place.
What to do this week
Where you go from here depends on your self-score in the fourth section.
If you landed in the first band, this list takes about fifteen minutes and most of it ends with “nothing to do”. That is a real result: you have checked, you know, and the red number can stop worrying you.
If you landed in the middle band, the second and third items matter most: what your past providers built is the fact everything else depends on. If you landed in the last band, work through every item in order, and keep your records as you go.
Checklist
Your toxic-links check
Saved on this device only
Whichever band you are in, the best protection against bad links is a profile full of good ones: customers, suppliers, local press and associations that link to you because you exist. The safe link building guide covers how to earn them, and the digital PR guide shows how a small business gets local press from its own data: the very kind of link a panic file throws away.
To see who links to you today, use the Links report in Search Console; no outside tool sees Google's own list. The free broken link checker on this site looks the other way, at the links on your own pages, and lists any that lead nowhere. It is a ten-minute tidy-up of the links you do control.
If your check turned up a manual action, the next guide, on Google penalties, picks up exactly where this one stops.
You reached the end
Your summary
This guide has 9 quick questions
Try them to see how much you already know. Your first answer is the one that counts.
Links and reputation: 0 of 3 read
- 1. Link building that won't get you in trouble: not read yet
- 2. Digital PR for small businesses: get local press from your own data: not read yet
- 3. Toxic links and disavow: what to do when a report says your site is in danger: this guide, not read yet
0 of 57 guides read · Saved on this device only
New guides by email when they are published.
Unsubscribe in one click.
What to do next
- Open Search Console, go to Security and manual actions, then Manual actions, and check whether it says “No issues detected”.
- If you have ever paid for an SEO package, email the provider and ask for a list of every link they built for you.
- If you already have a disavow file, download it and check it for local press, partners or associations before you upload anything new.
- If you find no manual action and no built links, decline any paid “toxic link removal” offer and spend that time earning one real local link.
Find the broken links on your site
Scan up to 50 pages for links that lead nowhere, with the page each one is on.
Scan for broken linksNext series: Measuring results
Measuring results
Google penalties: manual actions, algorithm drops and recovery
If Google penalised your site, it tells you, in writing. Here is where to look, and what it means if the notice is not there.
25 min readStart reading
Where we can help
Digital PR & links
Authority
Links you would be proud to show a journalist.
- Original data campaigns built for newsroom pickup
- Reactive commentary and journalist relationships
- Digital PR with named placement targets
From€2,880/moincl. VAT · cancel anytime
Still stuck?
Tell us your address and what changed, and we will point you to what applies.
Ask for a free SEO teardownSee it applied in an illustrative case study
Invented businesses and modelled figures, not client results: how the work in this guide fits into a whole engagement.
- Authority · 10 monthsIllustrative+93 referring domains, 14 national outletsPikeline Wild Trust
Trail-cam data that went viral: earning national coverage for a Colorado wildlife trust
Wildlife conservation nonprofit · Denver · North America
- Authority · 16 monthsIllustrative+192% wholesale enquiries from organicQantu Alpaca
Giving 140 Andean weavers a direct line to the world's knitwear buyers
Alpaca textile cooperative · Cusco · Latin America