Buying SEO · guide 3 of 5
SEO scams and red flags: how to protect your business
A field guide to the SEO offers that waste money or put your site at risk: guaranteed rankings, cheap link packages, fake Google calls and agencies that keep your accounts.
28 min readUpdated 9 Nov 2026
- 12 questions to test yourself
- 1 calculator
- 9-item checklist
On this page11 sections
The email that promised you page one
It arrives on a Tuesday morning. “I came across your website and noticed it is not ranking for your main keywords. We guarantee first-page results in 30 days, or your money back.” It uses your business name. It sounds just confident enough to be tempting.
Here is what most owners never find out: Google has written a help page about choosing an SEO, and it warns against exactly this kind of message. It even quotes one.
Quick quiz
Google’s own help page about hiring an SEO quotes a spam email that Google itself received. Before you read on: how do you think it begins?
Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.
That joke is also the first test you can use on any pitch: could this email have been sent, word for word, to anyone? If yes, it is not about your business.
By the end of this guide you will be able to count every red flag hidden in one sample pitch, know how to handle a caller who says they are “from Google”, and leave with a reply you can paste into the next cold email.
One more thing to watch for. The most expensive SEO trap has nothing to do with rankings, and you can rule it out in ten minutes. We will get to it after the phone scams.
To be fair up front: plenty of honest SEO freelancers and agencies exist, and some do send cold emails. The point is not to distrust everyone. It is to recognise the handful of tactics honest providers simply do not use.
What Google itself says about choosing an SEO
Google Search Central, the documentation Google publishes for website owners, has a page called “Do you need an SEO?”. It is short, free and worth ten minutes before you sign anything.
Its message is not that SEO is bad. It describes useful things a good SEO can do, such as reviewing your content and site structure and giving technical advice, and then lists what to be wary of. Test your instincts against it before you read the summary.
Myth or fact?
Guess first: what does Google’s page actually say?
1.For a fee, some companies can “priority submit” your site to Google so it ranks faster.
2.Google’s own guidance says no one can guarantee a number one ranking.
3.A money-back guarantee makes a ranking promise safe to accept.
4.A “Google Partner” badge means the agency has special influence over organic rankings.
5.Google suggests asking an SEO what they will do and how they will measure success before you hire them.
So the page warns against four things: guaranteed top rankings, emails out of the blue, a claimed special relationship or “priority submit” with Google, and providers who will not explain what they do.
It also gives a yardstick worth remembering: in most cases, it says, an SEO needs four months to a year to help a business first make improvements and then see potential benefit. Any pitch that promises results in days is promising something Google’s own documentation does not. Our honest SEO timeline guide shows what usually moves first in that window.
Inbox triage: six cold emails, six verdicts
Most bad offers are built from the same few sentences. Once you have seen them side by side, you start spotting them in the preview line, before you even open the message.
Below are six openings of the kind small businesses receive. They are illustrative examples written for this guide, not real companies. For each one, decide “red flag” or “fair opener” and say why, then flip. One of the six is honest; see if you can find it before you flip it.
Test yourself
Think of your answer, then flip the card.0 of 6 flipped
Guaranteed rankings and other impossible promises
A ranking guarantee sounds like the safest deal possible: if they fail, you pay nothing. In practice there are three ways it is usually made to work, and none of them helps you. The first is easiest to see with an example.
Quick quiz
Illustrative example: an agency guarantees a plumber in Leeds “top 3 for 10 keywords” and sends the list. Which of these lists should worry the plumber most?
Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.
So the first trick is choosing the keywords for you. Always ask which searches, and how many people make them. Our keyword research guide shows how to check that yourself.
The second is short-term tactics: a burst of bought links that may lift a page for a while, long enough to invoice. The third is fine print: “first page” of a search done from their office, or a money-back promise with so many conditions it never pays out.
Other impossible promises travel with it. “Number one on Google Maps” (map results change with where the searcher is standing). “Guaranteed AI mentions” (no one controls what an AI assistant writes). “Results in a week” (remember Google’s four-months-to-a-year yardstick).
Before and after
Two ways to describe the same three months
The pitch
Guaranteed page one for 10 keywords in 90 days. Our secret link network does the heavy lifting. No need to change your website. Price only valid this week.
An honest proposal
Month by month, what you get
Month 1: technical check and fixes to the problems that stop Google reading your pages. Month 2: rewrite the three service pages your customers search for most. Month 3: complete your Business Profile and start asking happy customers for reviews. We report what we did and what changed. We cannot promise positions; nobody can.
- The honest version names work you can check, not outcomes nobody controls.
- It involves your website and your profile, because that is where the improvements live.
- It has no deadline to sign. A good offer is still good next week.
Link packages and private blog networks
Links from other websites are one of the ways Google learns that a page is worth showing, which is exactly why they are sold. Google’s spam policies name “link spam” directly: buying or selling links that pass ranking credit, large-scale link exchanges, automated programs that create links, and similar schemes.
Before the details, try spotting one. Bought links tend to come from a particular kind of site.
Quick quiz
Illustrative example: three sites link to a roofer. Which one most likely sells its links?
Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.
A private blog network, often shortened to PBN, is a group of websites that exist mainly to link to paying clients. They often look like ordinary blogs at first glance, sometimes built on expired domains bought because they once had good links. Look closer and the articles are thin, the topics jump from mortgages to dog food, and every post links out to a business.
Google has said for years that its systems can detect and neutralise many spammy links. That sounds reassuring, until you remember that the links were what you paid for. And ignored is the good outcome.
If you want links without that risk, our guide to link building that won’t get you in trouble starts with the ones you already deserve: suppliers, trade associations and local partners.
Side by side
| Question | Bought link package | Earned links |
|---|---|---|
| Where the links come from | Sites built or paid to link to anyone | Local press, suppliers, associations, real blogs in your field |
| How many | Hundreds, quickly | A few, slowly |
| Would a customer ever click it? | Almost never | Sometimes, and that is the point |
| Allowed by Google’s spam policies | No, if bought to pass ranking credit | Yes |
| If Google discounts it | The money is gone | Nothing to discount |
What happens to a site after spam tactics
Google’s spam policies say that sites which violate them may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all. That can happen automatically, through Google’s systems, or through a manual action, where a person at Google reviews the site and applies a penalty that is reported to you in Search Console.
The pattern below is common enough to be worth knowing, but every site is different. Read it as an illustration of the shape, not a forecast.
Timeline
An illustrative year after a cheap link package
Month 1
The report looks great
Hundreds of new links appear in a spreadsheet. Rankings for a few phrases may tick up. Enquiries do not change much.
Months 2–6
Nothing much happens
Often the links are simply ignored by Google’s systems. You are paying monthly for links that count for nothing.
Some point later
A drop, or a message
Sometimes rankings fall after a Google update. Sometimes a manual action appears in Search Console for unnatural links.
Recovery
Cleaning up costs more than it saved
Removing or disavowing links, fixing the cause and, for a manual action, sending a reconsideration request. Then waiting while Google reprocesses the site.
Calls claiming to be from Google
A recorded voice says your Google listing is “about to be removed” or “not verified”, and to press 1 to speak to a specialist. The specialist then offers to verify or protect the listing for a fee. This kind of call has been common enough that Google’s Business Profile help pages warn about people pretending to be Google, and the US Federal Trade Commission has taken action against companies that made such calls.
The facts that defeat the call: creating and managing a Google Business Profile is free. Verification is something you do yourself, from inside your own profile, by the method Google offers you there (such as a video, a phone call, a text, an email or a postcard). Nobody needs your password or a verification code to “help”.
Google may occasionally contact businesses, for example to confirm opening hours, so a call alone is not proof of a scam. A demand for payment, a threat that your listing will vanish, or a request for a code or a login is.
What would you do?
The code that arrives mid-call
Illustrative example: a hair salon owner answers a call. A friendly voice says it is “Google Business support”: the listing will be suspended today unless it is re-verified. “I have just sent a code to your phone. Read it back and I will fix it for free.” A text with a six-digit code arrives.
What should the owner do?
Step by step
When the phone says it is Google
Step 1 of 5
Do not press anything or pay
Hang up politely. A real problem with your profile will still be there in five minutes, and you will check it yourself.
Hostage tactics: when the agency owns your accounts
Here is the trap promised at the start. Some of the most expensive SEO problems are not about rankings at all. They start the day you want to leave, when you discover that your domain, your website or your Google profile belongs, on paper, to the agency.
It happens quietly. The domain was registered “to save you the hassle”, with the agency as the owner. The site lives on the agency’s own platform with no way to export it. Your Business Profile has them as primary owner and you as a manager. Google Analytics and Search Console sit in their account. The phone number on your listings forwards through their call tracking.
None of this needs bad intent to become a problem: agencies close, freelancers move on. But a provider who refuses to put these in your name is telling you how leaving will go. The fix is simple while everyone is still friendly: you own every account, they get access as a user. Tick off what you can confirm today.
Checklist
Account ownership audit: who owns what?
Saved on this device only
What would you do?
The logins that never arrive
Illustrative example: a family restaurant ends its SEO contract after a year. It asks for the logins to its website and Google Business Profile. The agency replies that the accounts are “part of our platform” and offers a “handover package” for €900.
What should the restaurant do first?
Test your eye: how many red flags can you count in one pitch?
This is the pitch promised at the start. Every sentence in it uses a tactic from this guide. If you had seen it on day one, it might have sounded like a bargain. See how it reads now.
Make a guess
Read it once, counting every separate red flag you have learned to spot. How many did you find?
Anything within ±1 red flags counts as right.
What to do if you already paid
First, do not panic and do not pay anyone else to “fix it” in a hurry. Many sites that bought a link package see no penalty at all. The job is to protect your accounts, find out what was actually done, and then decide calmly.
Ask the provider, in writing, for a list of every link they built and every change they made to your site. An honest provider has this. A refusal is useful information too. Then compare it with the links report in Search Console.
If you paid for work that was never delivered, or was described falsely, keep every invoice and email. Depending on how you paid and where you are, your bank or card provider may have a dispute process, and consumer or trade bodies may help. Where money was taken by impersonating Google, report it to the police as fraud.
Put it in order
Put these steps in the best order after you realise an SEO deal was a bad one
Use the arrows to move each item, then check.
- Check Search Console for a manual action and review your links
- Decide on a dispute, a complaint or a clean-up with honest help
- Change passwords and remove the provider’s access to your accounts
- Ask in writing for a list of every link and change they made
- Save the contract, invoices, reports and emails
Try the numbers
What has your SEO bill bought so far?
Paid so far
€2,400
Paid per job you can name
€800
Your own numbers, not a verdict on value. A job is something you could point to: a page rewritten, a fix made, a real link earned. If you cannot name any, the two figures match, and that gap is exactly what your written request should ask about.
Not sure whether the links you paid for need cleaning up at all? Our guide to toxic links and disavow starts from the honest answer: most sites never need to act. For the rare case that does, the Fangolia Terme case study on this site follows a spa hotel through auditing and disavowing paid links that earlier agencies had bought. It is an illustrative study with an invented business, so read it for the steps, not the numbers.
Your scam-resistance score, and a reply for the next cold email
You do not need to become an SEO expert to be hard to scam. You need to own your accounts, know the few promises nobody can keep, and have a few questions ready for anyone who wants your money. Score yourself honestly; the result tells you where to start.
Score yourself
How well protected is your business?
I own my domain and know which registrar it is with
I own my Search Console, Analytics and Business Profile
I could name three red flags in a cold SEO email
I would hang up on a caller selling Google verification
Any SEO contract I have says what I keep if I leave
I know what the work I pay for each month actually is
0 of 6 answered. Answer them all to see your result.
Your reply for the next cold SEO email. Copy it, keep it, send it. An honest provider will answer every question in plain words. A scam usually goes quiet, or answers with another guarantee. If a provider passes these five and you are close to signing, our guide to choosing an SEO agency has 15 deeper questions and a way to score the answers.
“Thanks for getting in touch. Before we talk, please answer these in writing:”
- What exactly will you do in the first three months, and how will I see it?
- Which searches are you targeting, and how many people make them?
- Will every account be in my name, with you as a user?
- Do you follow Google’s Search Essentials, and will you build or buy links?
- How do I leave, and what do I keep when I do?
Questions people ask
Is every cold email about SEO a scam?
No. Some honest freelancers find clients that way. Judge the content: a specific, checkable observation about your site and no guarantees is a reasonable opener. A template, a guarantee or a deadline is not.
Should I use Google’s disavow tool on links an agency bought?
Google says most sites do not need the disavow tool. It is meant for cases where you have many spammy or artificial links pointing to you, especially with a manual action. Our guide on toxic links and disavow walks through when it makes sense.
Can an agency really get me into AI answers like ChatGPT or Google’s AI Overviews?
Nobody controls what an AI assistant writes. Good work can make your business easier to find and describe accurately, which may help, but a guarantee of AI mentions is the same impossible promise in new clothes.
Is a low price on its own a red flag?
Not always. A small, clearly described job can be cheap and honest. The warning sign is a low price for a big promise: page one, hundreds of links, all for less than a day’s skilled work.
You can now read a cold pitch the way Google’s own help page does. The next trap is quieter: an honest-looking audit that lists hundreds of “critical” issues, most of which will never cost you a customer. The next guide in this series, on reading an SEO audit, shows how to find the handful that matter and check the most important one yourself.
Before you go, run the free site check below on your own site. It takes about a minute, and next time an email tells you your site has 47 critical errors, you will already know what is really there.
You reached the end
Your summary
This guide has 12 quick questions
Try them to see how much you already know. Your first answer is the one that counts.
Buying SEO: 0 of 5 read
- 1. What SEO actually costs, and what you get at each price: not read yet
- 2. How to choose an SEO agency: 15 questions to ask before you sign: not read yet
- 3. SEO scams and red flags: how to protect your business: this guide, not read yet
- 4. How to read an SEO audit: find the five findings that matter in a 90-page report: not read yet
- 5. DIY SEO or hire help? How to decide by time, skill and risk: not read yet
0 of 57 guides read · Saved on this device only
New guides by email when they are published.
Unsubscribe in one click.
What to do next
- Look up your domain on ICANN Lookup (lookup.icann.org) to see which registrar it is with, then log in and confirm it is in your business’s name with auto-renew on.
- Open Google Search Console and check Manual actions, then confirm you are an Owner in Settings, Users and permissions.
- Check your Google Business Profile’s people and access list, make sure you are the primary owner, and remove anyone you do not recognise.
- Save the five-question reply from this guide and send it, unchanged, to the next agency that emails you.
Check your own site
Run our free site check: most of the technical points above, in under a minute.
Run the free checkNext in Buying SEO
Buying SEO
How to read an SEO audit: find the five findings that matter in a 90-page report
Your audit says you have 1,284 issues. Most of them will never cost you a single customer. Here is how to find the ones that might.
23 min readStart reading
Where we can help
Technical SEO
A good first stepSignal
Everything Google reads before it reads your words.
- Continuous crawl with regression alerting
- Core Web Vitals budgets enforced in CI
- Log-file analysis and crawl-budget shaping
From€1,068/moincl. VAT · cancel anytime
Which SEO plan fits your business?
See what each plan covers side by side, or answer three quick questions for a suggestion.
See it applied in an illustrative case study
Invented businesses and modelled figures, not client results: how the work in this guide fits into a whole engagement.
- Signal · 5 monthsIllustrative+112% online quote requestsTrakia Brokers
How a regional insurance broker rebuilt a slow, bloated site into a lead machine
Insurance brokerage · Stara Zagora · Bulgaria
- Signal · 9 monthsIllustrative+64% organic reservationsUrpi Picantería
How five Cusco picanterías turned photographed menus into dishes Google can read
Group of 5 picanterías · Cusco · Latin America