Buying SEO · guide 2 of 5
How to choose an SEO agency: 15 questions to ask before you sign
A buyer’s interview script for hiring SEO help: 15 questions, what good answers sound like, the evasive ones to watch for, and a way to score your shortlist.
24 min readUpdated 9 Nov 2026
- 8 questions to test yourself
- 1 calculator
- 30-item checklist
On this page10 sections
The question that tells you nothing
You have three agencies on your shortlist and 20 minutes with each. Most owners spend the first of those minutes on one question: “Can you get me to number one on Google?” Before you read on, pick the question you think would tell you the most.
Quick quiz
You have 20 minutes with an agency. Which question will tell you the most about how they work?
Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.
Any honest answer to “number one?” is no. Nobody controls Google’s rankings, and Google’s own page for people hiring an SEO says plainly that no one can guarantee a number one ranking. So the agency that says yes has told you it will over-promise, and the one that says no has told you nothing about whether it is any good.
This guide gives you 15 better questions, in the order a real call goes, with what a good answer and an evasive one sound like. Two of them protect you even if you end up picking the wrong agency: one about who owns your accounts, and one about a contract clause that can quietly turn a €600-a-month deal into a €7,200 bill. Both are flagged when you reach them.
At the end you will score each agency on your shortlist and get a verdict for it, plus the clauses to check before you sign.
Before you call: know your goal and your budget
The interview goes better when you arrive with two things written down. First, the one business result you want to move: more calls from people in your area, more online orders of one product line, more enquiries for your highest-value service. “More traffic” is not a goal; traffic that never becomes a customer is just a bigger number in a report.
Second, a budget range you are willing to say out loud. Owners often hide it, hoping the agency will propose something cheaper. Often the opposite happens: you get a generic package, priced to the agency’s average client. Give a range and ask, “What would you do at this level, and what would you leave out?” What they leave out is the most revealing part of the answer. Our guide on what SEO costs breaks down what different budgets can cover.
Finally, check what you already have. If a previous designer or agency set up your Google accounts, you may not have full access to your own data. Find out before the call, because one of the questions below is about exactly that. While you are at it, run our free site check on your homepage. It takes under a minute, and the handful of technical points it flags give you something concrete to listen for when you ask question 2.
Checklist
Have these ready before the first call
Saved on this device only
Questions 1 to 4: strategy and scope
These four tell you whether they have thought about your business or are about to sell you a package.
1. “What would you do first on our site, and why?” Listen for something specific to you, put in an order, with the order explained. Try judging three answers to it below before reading the rest.
2. “What have you already noticed about our site or our competitors?” A serious agency looks at least a little before a sales call. If the answer is “we will find out in the audit”, ask what the audit costs and what it will produce. If you ran the free site check, notice whether they mention anything it flagged: it took you a minute, so it should not take them longer.
3. “What exactly is included each month, in hours or deliverables?” You want quantities: “About 12 hours, which usually means one new page, fixes from the technical list and the monthly report.” Not “ongoing optimisation”, which can mean a lot of work or none.
4. “What will you need from us, and how much of our time?” Good agencies ask for things: access, photos, answers about your services, someone to approve pages. An agency that needs nothing from you is either not touching your site or planning to write about a business it does not know.
What would you do?
Three answers to “What would you do first?”
You run a small accounting practice and ask three agencies question 1. These answers are illustrative, but each pattern is common.
Which agency gets a second call?
Questions 5 to 7: who actually does the work
The person on the sales call is often not the person who will work on your site. That is normal. What matters is that you know who it is.
5. “Who will work on our account day to day, and can we speak to them before we sign?” A good answer gives you a role and ideally a name. A vague one is “our team of specialists”.
6. “Is any of the work done by another company?” Many agencies pass writing, links or development to subcontractors or white-label suppliers, meaning another firm does the work under the agency’s name. That is not wrong in itself. Being cagey about it is, because you cannot judge work when you do not know who did it.
7. “Can you show us work for a business like ours, and can we speak to a current client?” Look for a business with a similar size and type of customer, not a famous logo. Then ask that client one thing: “What did they get wrong, and how did they handle it?”
Test yourself
What that phrase might really mean
Think of your answer, then flip the card.0 of 5 flipped
Questions 8 to 10: reporting and access (you should own your accounts)
This is the first of the two questions that protect you even if you choose badly, and it is the easiest group to skip on a friendly call. When an agency relationship ends badly, the painful part is rarely the money. It is discovering that your Google Business Profile, your analytics history or even your domain sits in someone else’s account.
8. “Which accounts will be in our name, and what access will you have?” The only good answer: everything is in yours, and the agency gets user access that you can remove. That means your Google Search Console property, your Google Analytics property, your Google Business Profile, your domain registration, your hosting and your website’s admin. You stay the owner; they are added as users or managers.
If a past provider already holds some of these, the next guide in this series, SEO scams and red flags, has an account ownership audit you can work through in ten minutes.
9. “Can we see a sample monthly report?” Ask for a real one with the client’s name hidden. You will learn more from it than from the whole pitch.
10. “Which numbers will you treat as success?” Good agencies talk about enquiries, calls, bookings or sales from organic search, alongside the search numbers that lead to them. Be careful with an agency whose idea of success is mostly rankings for phrases they chose themselves. Our guide on which SEO numbers matter shows which figures lead to money and which only look good in a report.
What would you do?
A helpful-sounding offer
You run a small physiotherapy clinic. The agency you like says: “To save you the hassle, we will create your Google Business Profile and your analytics under our agency account. We manage everything for you there.” This is an illustrative example.
What do you say?
Side by side
Reading a sample report
| In the report | A good sign | Be wary of |
|---|---|---|
| Results | Enquiries, calls or sales from organic search, compared with the same month last year | Only rankings, with no link to enquiries or sales |
| Work done | A list of what was changed, written, fixed or built, with links you can check | “Ongoing optimisation” with no detail |
| Problems | What went down, and what they think caused it | Only good news, every month |
| Next month | What they will do next and what they need from you | Nothing about next month |
| Data source | Numbers from your own Search Console and Analytics | Numbers only from the agency’s own tool, which you cannot see |
Questions 11 to 13: links and risk
Links from other websites still help Google judge which pages deserve trust, which is why some agencies take shortcuts to get them. Google’s spam policies count buying or selling links that pass ranking credit as a link scheme. Breaking those policies can earn a manual action, a penalty a Google reviewer applies that shows up in the Manual actions report in Search Console, or a quieter drop in rankings. Either way, it is your site that pays, not the agency.
11. “How do you get links, and can you show us some you earned for a client?” Here is an answer you might hear. Judge it before reading on.
Quick quiz
You ask how they get links. They say: “Our package includes 20 high-authority links a month on our publisher network.” What is this?
Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.
A good answer describes real reasons another site would mention you: local press, partnerships, suppliers, useful resources, events. Earned links are hard to promise in fixed numbers, which is why a price list of “guest posts” or a set number of links a month deserves a follow-up. Our guide to link building that won’t get you in trouble shows what earned links look like for a small business, so you can tell whether the examples they show you are the real thing.
12. “Has a client of yours ever had a penalty or a sharp drop? What did you do?” Anyone who has worked in SEO for a while has seen a drop. A good agency tells you the story and what they learned. “Never” is either very new or not quite true. A good story also separates a manual action, which Google reports in Search Console, from an ordinary algorithm drop; our guide on Google penalties explains the difference.
13. “What would you refuse to do, even if we asked?” Good agencies have a ready answer: buying links, fake reviews, copying competitors’ content, hiding text. The question tells you whether they have lines at all, and the next statements show why that matters to you.
Myth or fact?
Things agencies say. Myth or fact?
1.“We have a special relationship with Google that gets our clients priority.”
2.Buying links that pass ranking credit is against Google’s spam policies.
3.If the agency breaks Google’s rules, the penalty falls on the agency.
4.An honest agency can give you a rough timeline even though it cannot guarantee results.
Questions 14 and 15: the contract
Many agency disputes come down to two things nobody discussed: how to leave, and what you keep.
14. “What is the minimum term, and what notice do we give to end it?” This is the second question that protects you. A first fixed period can be reasonable, because the early months are often setup work that pays off later. What to avoid is a long lock-in with automatic renewal and a long notice period. Get the term in writing; the calculator below works out when your notice is due.
15. “When we part ways, what do we keep?” The good answer: all the content, pages and site changes you paid for, every account in your name, and your data. Watch for clauses where the agency licenses you the content only while you are a client, or keeps the links it built on sites it controls, which can then be removed when you leave.
Try the numbers
What would a missed notice date cost you?
The promised example: a florist signs a 12-month contract at €600 a month that renews automatically for 12 more months unless cancelled 90 days before the end. She decides to leave in month 11, after the notice date. The renewal is already locked in, so on top of month 12 she owes another €7,200 for work she no longer wants. The florist is made up; the clause is not unusual.
Now put in the numbers from the proposal you are looking at.
Committed before you can leave
€7,200
Give notice by the end of
month 9
Extra owed if you miss that date
€7,200
Simple arithmetic on your own numbers, counting a month as 30 days, not legal advice. Your contract’s exact wording decides the real date and what you owe.
Look at the last number. If paying it would hurt, that is your negotiating point, and the time to raise it is before you sign: ask for a notice period of 30 days, or for the renewal to run month to month instead of for another full term. Many providers agree, and how they react to the request tells you something too.
Whatever you agree, put the notice month from the calculator in your calendar the day you sign, with a reminder a few weeks before it. The full list of clauses to check comes after the scoring section, because it is the last thing you do before signing.
The 15 questions on one sheet
Print this page or keep it open on your phone during the call. Tick each question as you ask it, and write a word or two beside it about the answer. After three calls, your notes will be more useful than any of the three pitches. Your ticks are saved on this device, so you can come back to them between calls.
Checklist
The interview sheet
Saved on this device only
Scoring your shortlist
Do this for each agency on your shortlist, ideally two or three. Score the answers, not the charm: the most likeable person on a call is not always the most useful one.
Score yourself
Score one agency’s answers
Score one agency straight after its call, while the answers are fresh. Then press reset and score the next one, and write each verdict on your sheet.
They named something specific about our site and what they would do first
They described the monthly work in hours or deliverables
We know who will do the work, including any other company
They showed relevant work and offered a client to speak to
Every account and the domain stay in our name
Their sample report shows enquiries or sales, work done and problems
Their link methods are earned, explained and shown
They told us what they would refuse to do, and promised no ranking
The contract term, notice and ownership are clear and fair
0 of 9 answered. Answer them all to see your result.
Two agencies with close scores? Pick the one whose first steps made the most sense to you. You will be working with that reasoning every month, and an agency you understand is one you can hold to account.
Once you have a winner, ask for their draft contract and go through it line by line with the list below. Anything it does not say clearly, ask them to add in writing before you sign.
Checklist
Before you sign: tick what the draft says clearly
Saved on this device only
What to do this week
Write down your goal and budget range, check who owns your Google accounts and domain, and book calls with two or three providers. That is enough to start. You do not need to understand SEO deeply to hire well; you need to ask questions that make the difference between good and evasive answers obvious.
One more read before those calls is worth it. The next guide in this series, SEO scams and red flags, takes the warning signs from questions 11 to 13 further: six cold emails to sort, the account traps that make leaving expensive, and one pitch to test how many red flags you can now spot on your own.
Questions people ask
Should I choose a freelancer or an agency?
Either can be excellent. A freelancer is often cheaper and you deal with the person doing the work; an agency can cover writing, development and SEO at once and does not stop when one person is ill. Ask the same 15 questions to both. Our guide on doing SEO yourself or hiring help covers the choice in more detail.
Should I pay for a trial or audit first?
A paid audit or a short first project is a good way to see how someone works before a long commitment. Ask what the audit will contain and whether you can use it with another provider. Our guide on reading an SEO audit shows what a useful one includes.
An agency emailed me out of the blue saying my site has problems. Should I reply?
Be careful. Google’s guidance for site owners advises being wary of SEO firms that contact you unsolicited. Some are genuine, but many cold emails are automated and identical. Our guide on SEO scams lists the most common ones.
Does Google say anything about hiring an SEO?
Yes. Google Search Central has a page called “Do you need an SEO?” with its own list of questions to ask, such as asking for examples of previous work and whether they follow Google Search Essentials. It also warns about guarantees, claimed special relationships with Google and unexplained techniques. It takes a few minutes to read and backs up most of this guide.
Is it a bad sign if they will not promise results?
No, it is a good one. They should promise the work, a plan and honest reporting. What happens in Google depends on Google and your competitors, which nobody controls.
You reached the end
Your summary
This guide has 8 quick questions
Try them to see how much you already know. Your first answer is the one that counts.
Buying SEO: 0 of 5 read
- 1. What SEO actually costs, and what you get at each price: not read yet
- 2. How to choose an SEO agency: 15 questions to ask before you sign: this guide, not read yet
- 3. SEO scams and red flags: how to protect your business: not read yet
- 4. How to read an SEO audit: find the five findings that matter in a 90-page report: not read yet
- 5. DIY SEO or hire help? How to decide by time, skill and risk: not read yet
0 of 57 guides read · Saved on this device only
New guides by email when they are published.
Unsubscribe in one click.
What to do next
- Write down the one business result you want and the budget range you are willing to share before you book any calls.
- Log in to Search Console, Google Analytics and your Business Profile and confirm you are the owner of each, not the agency or a former designer.
- Book calls with two or three providers and use the interview sheet above, ticking each question as you ask it.
- Score each one straight after the call, and check the winner’s contract against the clause list before you sign.
Check your own site
Run our free site check: most of the technical points above, in under a minute.
Run the free checkNext in Buying SEO
Buying SEO
SEO scams and red flags: how to protect your business
Google once got the same spam SEO email you did, addressed to google.com, and quoted it in its own help pages. Here is how to spot the rest.
28 min readStart reading
Where we can help
Technical SEO
A good first stepSignal
Everything Google reads before it reads your words.
- Continuous crawl with regression alerting
- Core Web Vitals budgets enforced in CI
- Log-file analysis and crawl-budget shaping
From€1,068/moincl. VAT · cancel anytime
Which SEO plan fits your business?
See what each plan covers side by side, or answer three quick questions for a suggestion.
See it applied in an illustrative case study
Invented businesses and modelled figures, not client results: how the work in this guide fits into a whole engagement.
- Signal · 8 monthsIllustrative+212% organic tour bookingsKilnaree Distillery
How an Irish distillery let Googlebot past its age gate and filled its tours from search
Pot-still whiskey distillery, 30 staff · County Clare · UK & Ireland
- Signal · 6 monthsIllustrative+145% organic booking requests by SeptemberLamplight Chimney Sweeps
How an 8-crew chimney sweep got its service pages back into Google before autumn
Chimney sweep & inspection company, 8 crews · Philadelphia · North America