Skip to content

Links and reputation · guide 1 of 3

Link building that won't get you in trouble

How a small business earns links from partners, local press and useful resources, in line with Google’s link spam policy, and how to spot the link offers that put a site at risk.

29 min readUpdated 9 Nov 2026

  • 10 questions to test yourself
  • 1 calculator
  • 9-item checklist
On this page12 sections

Someone told you that you “need backlinks”. Here is what that really means

Maybe it was an agency on a sales call, maybe a cold email offering “50 high-authority backlinks for €99”, maybe a friend who read it on a forum. The advice is half right. Links from other websites to yours do matter to Google. The half that is wrong is the idea that you should go out and buy them.

Buying links so they pass ranking value is against Google’s spam policies, in black and white. Earning them is slower, but an earned link also sends real visitors and real trust, and it is not the kind of link Google’s spam fighting is aimed at.

By the end you will have three things: a way to tell a safe link from a risky one in seconds, your own count of the link conversations you could start this month with people who already know you, and an outreach email people actually answer.

One more thing. There is a single word in those cold emails that, next to a price, tells you the offer breaks Google’s rules. We will come back to it once you know the rules. First, a question that catches out plenty of owners, and marketers too.

Quick quiz

You pay €500 to sponsor the shirts of your town’s youth football club. They add your logo and a link to your site on their “Our sponsors” page. What does Google’s guidance say about that link?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Why links matter, and why they matter less than the sales pitch says

In Google’s own “guide to Google Search ranking systems”, one of the named systems is link analysis, including PageRank, the idea Google started with in the late 1990s: a link from one page to another is a kind of vote, and votes from pages that are themselves important count for more. Google’s spam policies say it plainly too: links are an important factor in deciding how relevant a page is.

Links also do a quieter job. Google’s documentation on how Search works explains that Google discovers many new pages by following links from pages it already knows. A link from your trade association’s member list helps Google find you, and helps a human find you too.

Now the part the pitch leaves out. Links are one signal among many. A page that does not answer what the searcher wants will not rank because it has links, and a local business with a complete Google Business Profile, good reviews and clear service pages can do well with a handful of honest links. If the map results are what you care about most, the map pack guide covers the profile and review side; this guide covers the links. You are not trying to win a link-count contest. You are trying to be the business that people in your area and your trade would naturally point to.

Safe or risky? Test your instinct before the rules

Before reading Google’s policy, try your gut on six situations owners really run into. For each statement, decide: myth or fact? Each answer explains the rule behind it, so by the end of the six you will already know most of the policy.

Myth or fact?

Safe or risky? Six real situations

For each one: myth or fact?0 of 6 answered
  1. 1.A blogger offers to review your café and include a link if you send €80. Taking the deal with a normal link is fine as long as the review is honest.

  2. 2.A link from the manufacturer whose products you stock, on its “Where to buy” page, is a safe link to have.

  3. 3.Swapping links with one complementary local business you genuinely recommend is against Google’s rules.

  4. 4.Buying a “20 guest posts on high-DA sites” package with your keyword as the link text can count as link spam.

  5. 5.A local newspaper quoting you as an expert and linking to your site, without you paying, is a safe link.

  6. 6.Sending a free product to an influencer is against the rules even when they mark the link as sponsored.

What Google’s link spam policy actually says

Google Search Central publishes “Spam policies for Google web search”, and it has a section on link spam. Here is the short version of what it lists, when it is done to manipulate rankings. You have already met most of these in the six situations above.

  • Buying or selling links that pass ranking credit: money for links, or money for articles that contain links.
  • Exchanging goods or services for links, including sending someone a free product on condition that they write about it and link to you.
  • Excessive link exchanges (“link to me and I’ll link to you”) and partner pages that exist only to cross-link.
  • Large-scale article marketing or guest posting campaigns with keyword-rich anchor text (the clickable words of a link), and press releases or articles spread across other sites with optimised anchor text.
  • Using automated programs or services to create links to your site.
  • Text adverts and advertorials that pass ranking credit, and requiring a link as part of a contract or terms of service without letting the owner qualify it.
  • Low-quality directory and bookmark sites, forum comments and signatures stuffed with optimised links, and links hidden in widgets or spread across thousands of site footers.

Notice what is not on the list: advertising, sponsorship, affiliate deals, a supplier listing you as a stockist, a journalist quoting you, a partner who genuinely recommends you. Google asks that paid and sponsored links carry rel=“sponsored”, that links in comments and forum posts carry rel=“ugc” (user-generated content), and that rel=“nofollow” is used when nothing else fits. Google added “sponsored” and “ugc” alongside the older “nofollow” in 2019. All three ask Google not to count the link as a vote; Google says it treats them as hints rather than strict commands, which is why they are the honest fix and not a loophole. The link still works for people.

Google also says its systems can detect and neutralise unnatural links. For its December 2022 link spam update, it said it used SpamBrain, its AI-based spam prevention system, to spot both sites buying links and sites set up to pass them on. When Google’s team confirms a pattern by hand, the site can get an “Unnatural links to your site” manual action, which shows up in the Manual actions report in Search Console.

Side by side

QuestionEarnedPaid, marked sponsoredBought, unmarked
Allowed by Google’s spam policiesYesYesNo
Counts as a ranking voteIt canNo, by designNot if spotted, and it may cost you
Sends real visitorsOftenIf the site has readersRarely
Risk of a manual actionNoneNoneReal
SpeedWeeks to monthsAs fast as you payFast
A sponsored link is honest advertising: judge it like any advert, by the people who will see it. Link-selling sites seldom have real readers, which is why bought links rarely send visitors.

Start with the links you already deserve

Before you write a single outreach email, look at the people who already know you. If you have been trading for a few years, you probably have more relationships that could reasonably include a link than you think, and you have never asked for them. These are the easiest wins in this whole guide, because the other side already has a reason to say yes.

Turn each card below. The front is a relationship you probably have; the back is the link it can lead to and the one sentence to ask for it. Keep a rough count as you go: you will need it in a moment.

Think of your answer, then flip the card.0 of 8 flipped

Try the numbers

3
2
4
1

Link conversations you could start

10 people to ask

Send first: a listing they already keep

5 easy asks

At one short email each working day

2 weeks of asks

Your own count, not a forecast. Start with suppliers and memberships: they already keep a page of stockists or members, so you are asking them to complete a list, not to do you a favour. Not everyone will say yes, and some will already link to you, so check before you ask.

Local partnerships: the links that come with customers attached

The best local links come from businesses that share your customers but do not compete with you. A wedding venue, a florist, a photographer and a cake maker all serve the same couples. A physiotherapist, a running shop and a sports club serve the same runners. When one genuinely recommends another, the link is natural and the referral often matters more than the ranking.

The line Google draws is between recommendation and arrangement. A “Suppliers we love” page with five businesses you have actually worked with reads like advice. A page of fifty reciprocal links to businesses you have never met reads like a link scheme, because it is one.

What would you do?

The bakery next door

This is an illustrative example. You run a small coffee shop. The owner of the bakery that supplies your croissants emails: “Let’s help each other with SEO! I’ll add your link to every page footer of my site, you do the same, and let’s both join a link exchange group I found with 200 local businesses.”

What is the best reply?

Make one thing worth linking to

Journalists, bloggers, teachers and other businesses link to things that help their own readers. A page that only says “we are the best plumber in town” gives them nothing to point at. A page that answers a question nobody else in your area has answered well gives them a reason.

Before the ideas, test your editor’s eye on one real-world kind of choice.

Quick quiz

A primary school is updating its “Learning at home” page. Which page from a local garden centre’s site is it most likely to link to?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

You do not need a big budget. You need one resource that only you could make, because it uses what you know from doing the job every day. A few shapes that work for small businesses:

  • Your own numbers, honestly gathered: what you see across your jobs, bookings or orders over a year, such as which months boilers break down most in your area, with how you counted.
  • A calculator or checklist people use before buying: how much paint a room needs, what to ask before booking a wedding venue, what a dog needs for its first week home.
  • The definitive local guide to something you know: the best walking routes near your outdoor shop, where to park near your clinic, which permits a garden building needs in your municipality.
  • Original photos, diagrams or explainers that other sites would like to use with a credit.
  • A clear answer to the question customers ask you every week, written better than anyone else has written it.

Two things make a resource like this pay off twice. First, link from it to the page that actually sells: the bike shop’s route page ends with a line about its beginner bike fitting, so visitors, and Google, can follow the trail from the popular page to the one that earns money. The internal linking guide shows how to do that without stuffing.

Second, if your resource is your own numbers, it may be news as well as a link target. The digital PR guide, next in this series, shows how to turn something like “which months boilers break down most in our area” into a story a local journalist wants, and how to check the number before they do.

Outreach: how to ask without sounding like spam

Every site owner receives link requests, and most are deleted unread because they all look the same: “Dear webmaster, I loved your article, please add my link.” The emails that get answered are short, personal and give the reader something before they ask for anything.

Toggle between the two versions below and look at what changed.

Before and after

The same request, two ways

Deleted

Subject: Link collaboration opportunity

Dear Sir/Madam, I came across your website and loved your content. We are a leading provider of plumbing services. I think our website would be a great addition to your page. Could you add a link to us with the anchor text “best emergency plumber Sofia”? We can also offer a link back. Looking forward to hearing from you.

Answered

Subject: Your post on preparing a flat for winter

Hi Maria, I read your winter checklist for renters on the Lozenets residents’ blog. Point 4 about bleeding radiators is spot on. One thing readers often get wrong is the boiler pressure afterwards, so I wrote a short page with photos of what the gauge should show. If it is useful for your readers, here it is. Either way, thanks for the checklist: I have sent it to two customers. Ivan, a plumber in Lozenets.

  • A named person and a specific page, so it is obviously not a mass mailing.
  • Something for her readers, not just for the sender: the page fills a real gap in her post.
  • No anchor text demand and no link swap, both of which signal a link scheme.
  • An easy “no”: “either way” takes the pressure off, which makes “yes” more likely.
  • The example is illustrative: Maria, Ivan and the blog are made up.

Step by step

One outreach round, step by step

Step 1 of 5

Pick ten sites, not a hundred

Choose sites whose readers would genuinely benefit from your page: local blogs, community groups, trade publications, schools or clubs. Ten well-chosen sites beat a hundred scraped addresses.

Back to the “50 backlinks for €99” email: the one word that gives it away

Here is the kind of email this guide began with. You now know the rules well enough to read it the way Google’s policy does.

Quick quiz

Which word in that email describes exactly what Google’s link spam policy forbids?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

So here is the one-word test you can use for the rest of your life: if you are giving money or goods, and the deal requires a normal “dofollow” link, it is the thing the policy describes. Ask for rel=“sponsored” instead. If the seller refuses, you have learned what they were really selling.

To see what a profile built on links like these looks like, and what replacing them involves, read the Mapletrack Outfitters study on our Case studies page. It is illustrative, an invented canoe outfitter with modelled figures, whose only links were exact-match anchors from a paid directory network. You can load its link profile, day one and month 18, and watch the anchor mix level out as park, club and press links replace the directories. If you already bought links like these, the toxic links and disavow guide covers the clean-up, and when it is not needed at all.

Is this link worth chasing? Score any opportunity

Sooner or later someone will offer you a link, or you will spot a site you would love to be on. Run it through these six questions before you spend time or money.

Try it on the €99 email first. Answer honestly and it lands in “Walk away”, mainly because you do not even know which sites the links would be on. Then score a real opportunity of your own, such as the supplier or association at the top of your count.

Score yourself

  1. Real people read this site, and some of them could become my customers

  2. The site is about my area, my trade or my customers’ interests

  3. The link would sit in a page that is useful on its own, not in a list of hundreds

  4. Nobody wants money or goods for a normal link, and it is not a swap scheme

  5. I would be happy for a customer to click it and see where my business is mentioned

  6. I would still want this link if Google did not exist

0 / 12

0 of 6 answered. Answer them all to see your result.

Measuring: how to tell whether it is working

Link building is slow, so measure it in months, not days. One check every month or two, in three free places, is enough.

Step by step

Your 10-minute check, every month or two

Step 1 of 3

Search Console: has Google found new links?

Open the Links report in the left-hand menu. Under “External links” it lists your top linked pages, the top linking sites and the most common link text. New sites appearing there are links Google has found.

It is a sample rather than a complete list, so do not panic if a link you know about is missing.

Questions people ask

I already bought links in the past. What should I do?

First, open the Manual actions report in Search Console. If it says “No issues detected”, there is no manual action on your site. Stop buying, ask the sites to remove or mark the links where you can, and focus on earning new ones. Google says its systems often simply ignore unnatural links.

If there is an “Unnatural links to your site” action, the guide on toxic links and disavow walks through removal, the disavow file and the reconsideration request.

Should I disavow links I do not recognise?

Usually not. Google’s documentation says most sites do not need the disavow tool, and that it is meant for when you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links pointing to your site and they have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action. Random spammy links that every site collects are generally ignored.

Are guest posts always bad?

No. Writing a genuinely useful article for a publication your customers read is fine. What Google’s policy names is large-scale guest posting campaigns with keyword-rich links, written for the link rather than the readers. If the site would publish your piece without the link, you are on the right side.

How many links does a local business need?

There is no number, and anyone who quotes one is guessing. Compare yourself with the businesses that show up for your main searches, and aim to be as well connected locally as they are: the same trade bodies, the same local press, the same partners. Quality and relevance matter far more than the count.

What to do this week

You do not need a campaign. You need one hour, a spreadsheet and the people you counted earlier. Start at the top of this list: the first item makes sure there is nothing to clean up, and the next three turn your count into actual emails. Ticks are saved on this device, so you can come back to the list.

Checklist

Your first hour of safe link building

0 of 9 done

Saved on this device only

Once the easy asks are out, the links that move a small business furthest usually come from people who write: local journalists, trade magazines, community newsletters. They do not add you to a list; they need a reason to write about you. The next guide in this series, on digital PR, starts with your booking calendar or order history and ends with a pitch a reporter can say yes to.

And if your Links report turned up something that worries you, a block of strange sites or links you know were bought, read the toxic links guide before you touch the disavow tool. Most of the time the right move is to do nothing at all.

You reached the end

Your summary

This guide has 10 quick questions

Try them to see how much you already know. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Start with the first question
Your checklist0 of 9 done
Revisit the section “What to do this week”

Links and reputation: 0 of 3 read

  1. 1. Link building that won't get you in trouble: this guide, not read yet
  2. 2. Digital PR for small businesses: get local press from your own data: not read yet
  3. 3. Toxic links and disavow: what to do when a report says your site is in danger: not read yet

0 of 57 guides read · Saved on this device only

New guides by email when they are published.

Unsubscribe in one click.

What to do next

  1. Email the first two suppliers or manufacturers from your count today and ask to be added to their stockist or installer page.
  2. Search your business name in quotes and send one polite note asking for a link on an unlinked mention.
  3. Next time a link offer arrives, look for the word “dofollow” and run it through the six-question score before you reply.
  4. Pick one useful resource only your business could make, and list five sites whose readers would want it.

Find the broken links on your site

Scan up to 50 pages for links that lead nowhere, with the page each one is on.

Scan for broken links

Links and reputation

Digital PR for small businesses: get local press from your own data

Your booking calendar may already hold a story your local paper would run. Here is how to find it, check it and pitch it.

26 min readStart reading

See it applied in an illustrative case study

Invented businesses and modelled figures, not client results: how the work in this guide fits into a whole engagement.

See all 80 studies