Measuring results · guide 3 of 5
Google penalties: manual actions, algorithm drops and recovery
How to tell a real Google penalty (a manual action, shown in Search Console) from an algorithm change, and the recovery path for each, following Google's own spam policies.
25 min readUpdated 9 Nov 2026
- 11 questions to test yourself
- 1 calculator
- 9-item checklist
On this page11 sections
Is Google punishing your site? One report settles it
Your traffic fell, someone said the word “penalty”, and now it is all you can think about. Maybe an agency said the site was “flagged”. Maybe an email warned that Google had blacklisted you.
Here is the fact that settles most of these worries: when a person at Google takes action against your site for breaking its spam policies, Google tells you. The notice appears in the Manual actions report in Google Search Console, with the reason and the pages affected. If that report says “No issues detected”, you do not have a penalty in the sense most people mean.
That does not mean nothing happened. Google's automated systems change all the time and can move your pages down without anyone looking at your site. By the end of this guide you will know which of the two you are facing, how to check your own numbers for a seasonal dip, and which recovery path fits.
We will also come back to the one reaction that turns many small, survivable dips into lasting damage. It is not buying links, and most worried owners are tempted by it. First, test your instinct.
Quick quiz
An illustrative example: a made-up plumber's Google traffic halved in two weeks. The Manual actions report says “No issues detected”. What follows?
Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.
Manual actions and algorithm changes are different things
People use “penalty” for two very different events, and the recovery for each is different, so it pays to separate them early.
A manual action is a decision by a human reviewer at Google that some or all of a site breaks Google's spam policies. It is listed in Search Console, it names the problem, and once you fix it you can ask Google to look again.
An algorithmic change is Google's automated ranking systems re-weighing pages. Some updates target spam specifically; Google uses an AI-based system it calls SpamBrain for this. Others, the core updates Google announces a few times a year, re-assess quality and relevance across the web. Nobody sends you a notice, there is no request to file, and Google says a page that drops after a core update may have nothing wrong with it: other pages may simply now be judged more useful.
Side by side
| Question | Manual action | Algorithmic change |
|---|---|---|
| Who decided? | A person at Google, applying the spam policies | Automated ranking systems |
| Are you told? | Yes: Manual actions report in Search Console, usually with an email to the owners | No individual notice. Big updates are listed on Google's Search Status Dashboard |
| Does it say what is wrong? | Yes: the type of issue, and whether it affects the whole site or some pages | No. You infer it from the timing and which pages fell |
| How do you recover? | Fix the issue, then file a reconsideration request | Fix real problems and improve the pages, then wait for systems to reassess |
| How common for a normal small business? | Rare, unless spammy tactics were used | Most sites move up or down a little as updates roll out |
Where to check, in five minutes
You need access to the site's Google Search Console property. If you do not have it, ask whoever built or manages the site to add you as a user; it costs nothing and you should have it anyway. If you have never opened it, our 20-minute Search Console tour shows you the menus first.
Step by step
The five-minute penalty check
Step 1 of 5
Open the Manual actions report
In Search Console, open the left menu, find “Security & Manual actions” and click “Manual actions”.
A green tick with “No issues detected” means no manual action applies to this property right now.
Penalty or not? Four situations owners actually face
Most worried owners are in one of a handful of situations. The four below are illustrative examples. For each, decide first: manual action, or something else? Then flip the card to check.
Test yourself
Think of your answer, then flip the card.0 of 4 flipped
What would you do?
A sales call about a “penalty”
An illustrative example: a made-up bakery owner gets a call. An agency says it has “detected a Google penalty” on her site and can remove it for €900. Her traffic has dipped a little since last month.
What should she do first?
The manual actions you are most likely to see
Google's Manual actions report help page lists every type, with what triggers it and how to fix it. The names are short and a little cryptic, so here are the ones that most often reach small businesses, in plain words. If you have a notice open, find its name in the left column.
One more distinction matters: a manual action is either site-wide or a partial match, which affects only some pages or sections. The report tells you which, and lists a sample of affected URLs.
If yours is “Unnatural links to your site”, our toxic links and disavow guide shows how to sort a link export into remove, disavow and ignore without throwing away good links, and the Fangolia Terme case study on this site follows an invented spa hotel through auditing and disavowing paid links that earlier agencies had bought. If it is “Structured data issue”, our schema markup guide explains which markup a small business needs and why it must match the page.
Side by side
| Name in the report | What it means in practice | How to fix it |
|---|---|---|
| Unnatural links to your site | Links pointing at you look bought, swapped or built through networks to manipulate rankings. Often the legacy of a cheap link package years ago. | Remove what you can, disavow the rest, document it. |
| Thin content with little or no added value | Pages that add nothing: copied text, automatically generated pages, near-identical town pages, doorway pages. | Improve, merge or remove them. |
| User-generated spam | Spam left by visitors in comments, forums or profiles on your site. | Delete it, then add moderation, sign-up checks or comment filters. |
| Hidden text and/or keyword stuffing | Words hidden from visitors (white on white, tiny text) or keywords repeated unnaturally. | Remove them so what Google sees matches what people see. |
| Cloaking and/or sneaky redirects | Showing Google different content from visitors, or sending visitors somewhere they did not expect. Sometimes caused by a hack, not the owner. | Remove it and check for compromise. |
| Structured data issue | Schema markup that misrepresents the page, such as review stars for reviews that are not shown. Usually removes rich results rather than rankings. | Mark up only what is visibly on the page. |
| Site reputation abuse | Third-party pages hosted to borrow a site's standing in search, such as unrelated coupon or casino sections. In the spam policies since 2024. Rare unless you rent out space on your site. | Remove the pages or keep them out of Search. |
Quick quiz
A “Thin content” action is a partial match and lists three example town pages. You have 40 town pages built from the same template. What do you fix?
Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.
Spam policies: what is true and what is folklore
A lot of fear about penalties comes from things people have heard rather than what Google's spam policies say. Sort these out and you will know which risks to take seriously.
Myth or fact?
Six beliefs about Google penalties
1.Using AI to help write your pages is against Google's spam policies.
2.A competitor can easily get you penalised by pointing spammy links at your site.
3.Duplicate content between your own pages gets you penalised.
4.Buying links that pass ranking credit is against Google's spam policies.
5.A site can get a manual action for spam that visitors left in its comments.
6.Once a site is penalised, it can never fully recover.
Recovering from a manual action: the reconsideration request
If the report does show a manual action, the path is clear and entirely in your hands. Fix the problem on every affected page, not just the examples Google lists, then click “Request review” in the report. Google's reviewers read what you write, so the request is your chance to show the issue is really gone.
Google's guidance asks for three things in a good request: explain the exact quality issue, describe the steps you took to fix it, and document the outcome. Google says reviews can take several days or weeks, and it will tell you the result by email and in Search Console. Do not send repeat requests while one is pending.
Put the steps in the order that makes the request believable.
Put it in order
Put the recovery steps for an “Unnatural links to your site” action in order
Use the arrows to move each item, then check.
- Read the notice: site-wide or partial?
- Export your links and list the unnatural ones
- Ask site owners to remove them; keep a record
- Write the request: issue, actions, evidence
- Disavow the links you could not get removed
- Click “Request review” and wait
Before and after
Two reconsideration requests for the same problem (an illustrative example)
Weak
Hi Google, we did not know about these links and we have fixed everything. Please remove the penalty as soon as possible, our business depends on it.
Strong
The issue: in 2023 a previous agency bought links for us on 140 blog posts in a private network. We have listed every one in the attached spreadsheet.
What we did: we emailed every site owner twice. 96 links are now removed; dates and replies are in the sheet. We disavowed the 44 domains that did not respond. We have ended the contract and will not buy links that pass ranking credit.
The outcome: a link export dated last week shows none of the network links remain live and undisavowed.
- The strong version names the issue, takes responsibility, gives numbers and points to evidence. The agency, years and numbers are made up.
- The weak version asks for a favour. A reviewer cannot verify “fixed everything”.
Recovering from an algorithmic drop
There is no form for this. You cannot ask Google to reverse a core update, and nobody can promise you will get your old positions back. What you can do is remove genuine reasons for systems to rate your pages lower, and give them time to reassess.
Start by finding out what actually fell. In Search Console's Performance report, compare the four weeks after the drop with the four weeks before, then look at the Pages and Queries tabs. A drop spread across every page points one way; a drop concentrated in, say, your blog posts or your town pages points another. Then put one of the pages that lost most into the free SEO check on this site: in under a minute it reads the title, headings, structured data, robots.txt and sitemap, which rules out the quick technical breaks before you blame an update.
Try the numbers
Is it Google, or the time of year?
Change this year
-30%
Same weeks last year
-8%
Gap the season does not explain
-22 points
Take the four numbers from Search Console's Performance report (it keeps about 16 months of data) using “Compare” on the date range. The gap is in percentage points: this year's change minus last year's. Your own numbers, an estimate only, not a diagnosis.
Now read your gap. If it is close to zero, last year's pattern explains most of the fall: the season is the likelier cause, and changing the site in response would be treating the wrong problem. If the gap is clearly below zero and the fall lines up with an update on the Status Dashboard, an algorithmic reassessment becomes a reasonable explanation. Then look at the pages that lost most.
For a core update, Google's documentation suggests asking hard questions of the pages that lost out: do they offer original information, a complete answer and real expertise, or do they mostly repeat what is already out there? For a spam update, check your site against the spam policies line by line. Google has said that once a site complies, its automated systems can take months to learn that and adjust.
To see that calm approach applied to a whole site, read the Fenerche Lamps study on our Case studies page: an illustrative lamp shop in Plovdiv whose slow product pages slid during a core update, and which traced the fall to one clear cause, pages far too slow on phones, and fixed that before measuring again.
The panic reaction that turns a dip into lasting damage
Now the reaction we promised to come back to. The most damaging response to an algorithmic dip is changing many things at once before you know the cause.
A dip can recover as systems reassess. A panicked rebuild, a mass disavow or a mass deletion can remove the very things that were still working, and leaves you unable to tell which change helped or hurt. The usual forms it takes:
- Rebuilding or redesigning the whole site before you know the cause, which adds a migration risk on top of the drop
- Disavowing hundreds of links because a tool coloured them red, when no manual action asked for it
- Deleting large numbers of pages that still bring enquiries, just because they lost some positions
- Buying a “recovery package” from someone who cannot say what exactly they will change
- Changing everything at once, so you can never tell which fix helped
What would you do?
Traffic fell during a core update
An illustrative example: a made-up home-cleaning company in three cities lost about a quarter of its Google clicks during a core update. The drop is concentrated in 60 near-identical “cleaning in [suburb]” pages, written from one template. Its main service pages held steady.
What is the most sensible response?
Timeline
What recovery usually looks like
Day 1
Check, do not guess
Manual actions, Security issues, the Status Dashboard dates, and whether analytics and Search Console agree.
Week 1
Find the pattern
Which pages and queries fell, and by how much. Write it down so you can measure change later.
Weeks 2–8
Fix the real problems
Improve, merge or remove weak pages. Clean up spam, hacked content or link schemes. Avoid rebuilding the whole site in a panic.
Months 2–6+
Let systems reassess
Google says changes can take months to be reflected, and some sites see movement only around a later update. Keep publishing useful work meanwhile.
Prevention: the habits that keep you out of trouble
For most small businesses, avoiding a manual action is not hard. Look back at the table of common actions: nearly every one comes from a tactic someone chose, such as a link package, a batch of auto-written pages or copy-paste town pages, or from a hack or spam that piled up unnoticed.
Rate your site honestly. Each answer that is not a clear yes shows you where to look first.
Score yourself
How exposed is your site?
I can log in to Search Console and receive its emails
Nobody has bought links for the site, or any paid links are marked sponsored
Every page that targets a town or service has information specific to it
Comments, forums and sign-up forms are moderated or protected from spam
The site's software and plugins are kept up to date
Review stars and other markup only describe what is visible on the page
Anyone working on our SEO tells us exactly what they do
0 of 7 answered. Answer them all to see your result.
Checklist
Your penalty check and recovery list
Saved on this device only
Questions owners ask
Questions people ask
Can I have a penalty that does not show in Search Console?
Not a manual action: those are reported there. What you can have is an algorithmic drop, a technical problem, or a security issue (which has its own report). People often call all of these “penalties”, which is why the word causes so much confusion.
Should I use the disavow tool just in case?
Google says most sites do not need it, and disavowing good links by mistake can hurt. It is meant for when you have a manual action for unnatural links, or you know there are many paid or schemed links pointing at you that you cannot get removed.
Will moving to a new domain escape a penalty?
It is a risky gamble. Redirecting a penalised site can carry the problem across, and not redirecting throws away everything the old domain earned. Fixing the issue is almost always the better path.
My manual action was lifted but traffic did not come back. Why?
Lifting the action removes the penalty, not the cause of past rankings. If bought links or thin pages used to help, they no longer do. From here, rankings depend on the site's real strengths, which you can build.
Where you go next depends on what your two reports said.
- Both clear: the traffic drop checklist, next, walks the other suspects in order, from tracking to technical breaks to competitors.
- “Unnatural links to your site”: the toxic links and disavow guide, then safe link building so the problem does not come back.
- “Thin content”, or town pages from one template: the guide to location and service pages that are not copy-paste spam.
- Someone is selling you a penalty fix: the SEO scams guide lists the other red flags to check them against.
You reached the end
Your summary
This guide has 11 quick questions
Try them to see how much you already know. Your first answer is the one that counts.
Measuring results: 0 of 5 read
- 1. My Google traffic dropped: a calm diagnosis checklist: not read yet
- 2. Google Search Console for business owners: the 20-minute tour: not read yet
- 3. Google penalties: manual actions, algorithm drops and recovery: this guide, not read yet
- 4. GA4 for SEO: the three reports that show what Google brings you: not read yet
- 5. Which SEO numbers matter (and which ones only look good in a report): not read yet
0 of 57 guides read · Saved on this device only
New guides by email when they are published.
Unsubscribe in one click.
What to do next
- Open Search Console today and look at both the Manual actions and Security issues reports for the property people actually visit.
- Put your own clicks into the season check, comparing the four weeks before and after the drop with the same weeks last year.
- If both reports are clear, work through the traffic drop checklist before changing anything on the site.
- Ask anyone who has done SEO for you, in writing, whether they bought or arranged links.
Check your own site
Run our free site check: most of the technical points above, in under a minute.
Run the free checkNext in Measuring results
Measuring results
My Google traffic dropped: a calm diagnosis checklist
Many “traffic drops” turn out to be a broken tracking tag or a holiday week. Here is how to tell in ten minutes, and whether to worry at all.
29 min readStart reading
Where we can help
Technical SEO
A good first stepSignal
Everything Google reads before it reads your words.
- Continuous crawl with regression alerting
- Core Web Vitals budgets enforced in CI
- Log-file analysis and crawl-budget shaping
From€1,068/moincl. VAT · cancel anytime
Still stuck?
Tell us your address and what changed, and we will point you to what applies.
Ask for a free SEO teardownSee it applied in an illustrative case study
Invented businesses and modelled figures, not client results: how the work in this guide fits into a whole engagement.
- Signal · 9 monthsIllustrativeFrom 32% to 94% of episode pages indexedHushmark Podcasts
How a 14-show podcast network spliced out 30,000 thin pages and got its episodes indexed
Independent podcast network, 14 shows · New York · North America
- Signal · 8 monthsIllustrativeLevel on all three Core Web Vitals, then +64% organic enquiriesIvelstone Garden Rooms
How a garden-room builder kept its 3D configurator and still got its pages level on a phone
Garden office & garden room builder, 25 staff · Exeter · UK & Ireland