Skip to content

Measuring results · guide 5 of 5

Which SEO numbers matter (and which ones only look good in a report)

Vanity metrics, leading and lagging indicators, a one-page report template and the questions that show whether SEO is turning into enquiries and revenue.

23 min readUpdated 9 Nov 2026

  • 13 questions to test yourself
  • 1 calculator
  • 8-item checklist
On this page11 sections

Forty numbers in the report, and the one question you actually have

Every month a PDF arrives. Twelve pages, a dozen charts, green arrows pointing up. Keywords tracked: 340. Domain score: up 4. Impressions: up 18%. And you still cannot answer the only question you care about: is this bringing in customers?

Rankings do not pay bills; enquiries do. That does not make rankings useless. It makes them early signals, and an early signal is only worth something if you know what it is supposed to lead to.

If you have last month’s report to hand, open it next to this page. You will use it three times: to price your own organic traffic, to rebuild page one of the report, and to score it at the end.

Further down there is a chart that makes owners want to email their agency in a panic, even though, read properly, it shows a good quarter. By the time you reach it, you will see why. First, a gut check.

Quick quiz

Four numbers from a typical monthly SEO report. Which one is closest to money in your bank account?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Vanity metrics: numbers that can rise while the phone stays quiet

A vanity metric is not a fake number. It is a real number that can improve without your business improving. That is what makes it dangerous: it looks like progress, so nobody asks the next question.

The usual suspects in small-business reports:

  • Total keywords ranked. Easy to inflate with searches on page 5 or ones unrelated to what you sell.
  • Third-party authority scores (Domain Authority, Domain Rating, Authority Score). These are made by SEO tool companies to estimate link strength. Google does not use them, and Google staff have said so publicly more than once.
  • Total backlinks. A thousand links from junk directories can be worth less than one from your local newspaper, and some can cause trouble.
  • Total traffic with no split. A blog post that went viral abroad can double sessions without a single local customer.
  • Your ranking when you search from your own phone. Google adjusts results for location and other factors, so what you see in your shop is not what a customer across town sees.
  • Impressions on their own, for every query, with no filter for the searches that matter to you.

Myth or fact?

Vanity or valuable? Decide before you read the answer

For each one: myth or fact?0 of 5 answered
  1. 1.If your Domain Authority goes from 22 to 31, Google now trusts your site more.

  2. 2.Clicks from Google to your service and product pages are worth more attention than clicks to old blog posts.

  3. 3.Ranking for more keywords is always a sign SEO is working.

  4. 4.A rise in searches for your business name usually has causes beyond SEO.

  5. 5.Organic enquiries rising while total traffic stays flat can be a good month.

Leading indicators: the early signs that something is moving

Leading indicators move first. They do not pay you, but they tell you weeks or months in advance whether enquiries are likely to follow. Lagging indicators are the results themselves: enquiries, customers, revenue. They move last and are what you are actually paying for.

You need both. Watching only lagging numbers means you find out about a problem months late. Watching only leading numbers means you can celebrate for a year without making a sale.

The leading indicators worth tracking, all free in Google Search Console (if you have never opened it, the Search Console 20-minute tour in this series shows where each of these lives):

  • Pages indexed: are the pages that sell for you actually in Google? (Search Console’s Pages report, under Indexing.)
  • Impressions for your money searches: the services, products and places you want to be found for, not every query.
  • Position for those same searches, read as a trend over months, not a daily score.
  • Clicks to your money pages, and the click-through rate (clicks divided by impressions) for each.

Put it in order

Put these in the order they happen, from the first sign to money in the bank

Use the arrows to move each item, then check.

  1. The page starts appearing for relevant searches (impressions)
  2. Google indexes your service page
  3. A visitor calls or sends the form (enquiry)
  4. The enquiry becomes paid work (revenue)
  5. Searchers choose your result (clicks)

Test yourself

Translate the report jargon. Think of the meaning, then flip

Think of your answer, then flip the card.0 of 6 flipped

Lagging indicators: the numbers that pay the bills

The lagging indicators are a short list: organic enquiries (forms, calls, bookings, emails, chats), how many of those become customers, and what those customers are worth. If you sell online, add organic orders and revenue, which your shop platform or Google Analytics can usually show.

These are the hardest numbers to get, which is exactly why many reports skip them. Calls are the classic gap: a customer finds you on Google, rings the number on your Business Profile, and no website tool ever knows. Three simple ways to close it:

  • Mark phone-link clicks and form sends as key events in Google Analytics (the GA4 for SEO guide shows where).
  • Check the calls and website clicks in your Google Business Profile performance view.
  • Ask every new customer “How did you find us?” and write the answer down. A notebook counts.

Make a guess

Your site turns 2% of visitors into enquiries. A clearer page lifts that to 3%. How much more traffic would bring the same extra enquiries, with the page unchanged?

10% more traffic
0%200%

Anything within ±10% more traffic counts as right.

One more filter before you calculate. Branded searches include your business name; non-branded ones are things like “emergency plumber Plovdiv”. In Search Console you can filter queries that do or do not contain your name. Non-branded clicks are the clearest measure of what SEO itself is winning you, so use those in the calculator.

To see the split used as the headline number, read the Elderhof Brauerei case study on this site: an invented brewery that ranked only for its own name, tracked by non-branded visits and trade enquiries rather than total traffic.

Try the numbers

What is your organic traffic worth? Put in your own numbers

Take non-branded clicks to your money pages from Search Console (or your report). Enquiry rate is enquiries divided by those visits; close rate is how many enquiries become paying customers. Do not know them yet? Try a few values and watch the last two lines.

300 clicks
3%
30%
€400

Revenue a month from organic customers

€1,080

Added by +1 point of enquiry rate

€360 a month

Extra clicks needed to match that

100 more clicks

An illustration built from your own inputs, not a forecast. Real enquiry and close rates vary hugely by trade, price and season; measure yours for a few months before relying on them.

Look at the last two lines. The first is what one more percentage point of enquiry rate is worth to you each month; the second is how many more clicks a month it would take to earn the same from traffic alone.

If a visible phone number, a price range or a shorter form is cheaper for you than winning that many clicks, the page is where the next month of work should go. Either way, it is a fair question to put to whoever does your SEO: which of these two levers are we pulling?

The panic chart: why the average can get worse in a good quarter

Here is the chart promised at the start. Average position is the number most often used to declare success or failure, and it is the one that misleads owners most often. Decide what you would do before reading the outcomes.

What would you do?

The worrying chart

Your report says average position got worse, from 8 to 14. In the same three months, impressions doubled and clicks to your service pages rose from 120 to 160 a month.

Your first instinct is to email the agency asking what went wrong.

What is the most likely explanation?

Side by side

How a good quarter drags the average down

Illustrative numbersBeforeAfter
Searches you appear for50250
Average position, the original 5088
Average position, the 200 new onesNone yet15.5
Overall average position814
Clicks to service pages a month120160
Made-up numbers, with every search counted equally to keep the sum simple: (50 × 8 + 200 × 15.5) ÷ 250 = 14. Search Console’s own calculation is more detailed, but new low positions pull it down the same way, even though nothing you had got worse.

A one-page report template you can ask for

A good monthly report fits on one page before the appendix. It answers three questions in order: did we get business from search, are the early signs moving, and what was done and what comes next. Everything else can live in the attachment for anyone who wants it.

Compare months with the same month last year as well as with last month, so a seasonal business does not panic every January. Search Console keeps 16 months of performance data, which is just enough for that.

Lay your own report next to the example below. Which version is yours closer to?

Before and after

The same month, summarised two ways

Typical report

Great month! Keywords ranked up 21%. Domain Authority up 3 points. 47 new backlinks acquired. Impressions up 18%. Average position 12.4. Bounce rate 61%. See pages 2–14 for full keyword table.

One-page report

October, compared with October last year

Results: 23 enquiries from organic search (last year 17). 9 became customers, by your notes.

Early signs: non-branded clicks to service pages 410 (last year 290). The “boiler repair” page moved onto page one for its main searches.

Work done: rewrote two service pages, fixed 14 broken internal links, replied to 6 reviews. Next month: a page for the new heat-pump service.

  • The second version starts with money, then the signals that predict it, then the work. You can read it in a minute.
  • Every number in it is tied to something you sell, and compared with a fair baseline.
  • This is an illustrative example: the business and figures are made up.

Checklist

Build your report: tick what yours should include

0 of 8 done

Saved on this device only

Reading a report you did not write

When a long report lands, you do not need to understand every chart. Read it with five questions, and notice whether the report answers them or steps around them.

If the report comes with a long audit attached, the guide on how to read an SEO audit sorts the findings that matter from the filler. If you are choosing who should report to you in the first place, the 15 questions in how to choose an SEO agency include asking to see a sample report.

  • Where are the enquiries? If the report never mentions forms, calls or sales, ask whether tracking is set up. Often it is not.
  • Is this branded or non-branded? Growth that is all branded may simply be your reputation at work.
  • Compared with what? A percentage without a baseline, a date range or last year’s figure is hard to judge.
  • Which pages? Traffic to the pages you earn from matters far more than site-wide totals.
  • What changed because of the work? Ask which numbers moved after which piece of work, and accept “too early to tell” for anything done in the last few weeks.

Myth or fact?

Three things owners often get wrong when reading reports

For each one: myth or fact?0 of 3 answered
  1. 1.A drop in organic traffic in a single week is a reason to change strategy.

  2. 2.Search Console and Google Analytics will usually show different numbers for the same month.

  3. 3.If Search Console does not list a search, nobody found you through it.

Mistakes that make SEO look better or worse than it is

  • Judging new work after two weeks. Fresh pages and changes can take days or weeks to be crawled and months to settle; judge leading indicators first. The honest timeline in how long SEO takes shows what to expect when.
  • Counting every enquiry as SEO. If you also run ads or a big referral push, ask how the report separates them.
  • Tracking 300 keywords. Choose 10 to 30 that match what you sell and where; that list is easier to read and harder to game.
  • Changing the tracking mid-year. If key events or filters change, note the date, or the comparison with last year is meaningless.
  • Ignoring the page after the click. If clicks rise and enquiries do not, the next job is the page and the offer, not more traffic.

What would you do?

More visitors, same silence

Over four months, non-branded clicks to your “kitchen fitting” page went from 90 to 210 a month. Enquiries from that page stayed at about four a month. Your agency proposes writing more blog posts to bring in more traffic.

This is an illustrative example: the business and figures are made up.

What would you ask for next?

How good is your current reporting?

Now score the report you opened at the start, or the reporting you have today, whether it comes from an agency, a freelancer or your own spreadsheet. Be honest: the result is only for you, and each band tells you the single next thing to fix.

Score yourself

Your SEO reporting, point by point

  1. Form sends and phone clicks are tracked as key events in Google Analytics

  2. I know roughly how many enquiries a month come from Google Search

  3. I know roughly how many of those become customers

  4. My report separates branded and non-branded searches

  5. My report shows the pages I earn from, not just site totals

  6. My report compares with the same month last year

  7. I could explain the main number in my report to my business partner in one sentence

0 / 14

0 of 7 answered. Answer them all to see your result.

Questions owners ask about SEO numbers

Questions people ask

What is a good click-through rate?

There is no single good number. It depends heavily on position, the type of search, and what else sits on the page: ads, a map, an AI answer. Compare a page with itself over time, and look for searches where you rank well but few people click.

How often should I look at SEO numbers?

Monthly is enough for most small businesses, with a quarterly look at the bigger trend and the keyword list. Checking daily mostly produces worry.

Should I pay for a rank-tracking tool?

Not to start. Search Console shows the searches you actually appear for, for free. A tracker helps if you want daily positions for a fixed list, or competitor comparisons, but it is a leading indicator like any other.

My traffic is down but enquiries are up. Is that possible?

Yes. Losing visits to old or off-topic content while gaining on money pages can do exactly that. AI answers and other features on the results page can also mean fewer clicks for simple questions. Follow the enquiries.

Your weakest link decides what you read next

You now know which numbers lead to money. The useful next step is to find where your own chain from impression to customer breaks, and fix that link before anything else. Pick the line below that sounds like your report:

  • “We cannot see enquiries at all.” Start with GA4 for SEO: key events first, then the landing pages report.
  • “Lots of impressions, few clicks.” Read title tags and meta descriptions that earn clicks.
  • “Clicks are up, the phone is not.” Read conversion basics: the page is where the leak is.
  • “The numbers suddenly fell.” Work through the calm traffic-drop diagnosis checklist before changing anything.

You reached the end

Your summary

This guide has 13 quick questions

Try them to see how much you already know. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Start with the first question

New guides by email when they are published.

Unsubscribe in one click.

What to do next

  1. Open Google Analytics and check that form sends and phone-number clicks are marked as key events; if not, set them up or ask whoever runs your site.
  2. In Search Console, filter Performance to queries that do not contain your business name and note the clicks to your three main money pages.
  3. Start a simple log of new enquiries this month with one column: “How did you find us?”
  4. Send your agency or freelancer the report checklist above and ask for page one to follow it from next month.

Check your own site

Run our free site check: most of the technical points above, in under a minute.

Run the free check

Planning a website

Conversion basics: small changes that turn visits into leads

Going from 1.5% to 2% of visitors enquiring sounds tiny. On 1,500 visits a month, it is worth as much as 500 extra visitors. Here is where the leaks hide.

28 min readStart reading

See it applied in an illustrative case study

Invented businesses and modelled figures, not client results: how the work in this guide fits into a whole engagement.

See all 83 studies