Skip to content

Planning a website · guide 5 of 7

WordPress, Shopify, Wix or custom? Choose once, not twice

How to choose a website platform by what your business needs, what it really costs over three years, how much SEO control you get and how hard it is to leave.

21 min readUpdated 9 Nov 2026

  • 9 questions to test yourself
  • 1 calculator
  • 9-item checklist
On this page10 sections

Most platforms can rank. The question is fit

Nobody regrets their platform on launch day. The regret comes two years later: the shop has outgrown the builder, or the person who set up WordPress has stopped answering, and the fix is paying for the same website twice.

Ask five web designers which platform to use and you will hear five answers, usually the one each of them builds on. That is not dishonest: people recommend what they know. But it means the advice is about them, not about your business.

By the end of this guide you will have a shortlist of one or two platforms, a three-year cost for each in your own numbers, and a personal result that says how much platform you actually need.

There is also one question, two minutes to ask, that decides whether leaving a platform later costs you a weekend or a full rebuild. Most owners never ask it. We will come to it in the section on lock-in. First, a quick test of the belief that makes most people choose for the wrong reason.

Quick quiz

Which website platform does Google give a ranking advantage to?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Start with what the site must do, not with the platform

Owners often start by comparing platforms feature by feature. That is backwards. Thousands of features look useful in a demo; you will use a dozen. Start with a short list of the jobs your site must do in the next two or three years, then see which platform does those jobs with the least effort.

Write down, in plain words: what a visitor should be able to do (call, book, buy, ask for a quote), who will update the site and how often, how many pages you expect, whether you need more than one language, and which other systems it must talk to, such as a booking calendar, a stock system or an accounting tool.

Each of those answers quietly rules platforms in or out. Before you flip each card below, guess which platform the owner should shortlist. Then flip and see if you were right.

Test yourself

Think of your answer, then flip the card.0 of 5 flipped

The four options, in plain terms

WordPress is the free software from WordPress.org that you install on hosting you pay for (WordPress.com is a hosted service built on it). W3Techs, which tracks the technology behind websites, has for years reported it running over 40% of all websites. Finding a developer is rarely the problem. Keeping the plugins updated is.

Shopify is a hosted shop: a monthly plan, and Shopify runs the servers, checkout and payments from day one. Extra features come from apps, many with their own monthly fee.

Wix and Squarespace are hosted builders: drag, drop, publish, and updates are their problem. The quickest way to a decent site, and the most closed if you ever leave.

Custom means a developer builds it in code. You get exactly what you asked for, and you depend on whoever wrote it.

The table puts them side by side. Read the last row twice: it is the one owners skip, and the one this guide comes back to.

Side by side

The four options side by side

What you care aboutWordPressShopifyWix / SquarespaceCustom
Best fitContent sites, services, shops via WooCommerceOnline shops of any sizeSmall service sites, portfoliosUnusual features or integrations
Who runs the serversYou or your hostShopifyThe builderYou or your developer
Editing without a developerYes, once set up wellYesYes, the easiestOnly if an editor was built in
SEO controlVery high, often via pluginsGood; some fixed URL partsGood for the basicsTotal, if someone builds it
Upkeep you must doMonthly updates: core, theme, pluginsLittle; review your appsVery littleWhatever the contract covers
Leaving laterEasy: content exports, any hostMedium: products export, design staysHard: the design does not moveDepends on who owns the code
A general comparison, not a ranking. A well-run site on any column can outperform a neglected one on another.

SEO control: what you can and cannot change

“SEO control” sounds abstract. In practice it is a short list of things you will one day want to change: the page title and description Google may show, the URL of each page, redirects when a page moves, which pages Google should not index, structured data (code that describes your business or products to search engines), image alt text, and how fast pages load.

Owners arrive at this decision carrying beliefs they picked up from forums and sales calls. Before the details, sort these five into myth or fact. One of them has talked plenty of owners into moving a site that never needed to move.

Myth or fact?

Five beliefs about platforms and SEO

For each one: myth or fact?0 of 5 answered
  1. 1.Wix sites can't rank on Google.

  2. 2.Too many apps or plugins can slow a site down, whatever the platform.

  3. 3.On Shopify, you can remove /products/ from product URLs if you install the right app.

  4. 4.Moving to a new platform can lose Google traffic even if the content stays the same.

  5. 5.Installing an SEO plugin on WordPress does SEO for you.

The short version: every mainstream platform now lets you edit titles, descriptions, alt text and redirects. The differences are at the edges.

Shopify fixes part of every address: /products/, /collections/, /pages/ and /blogs/. That is a quirk, not a penalty; many large shops rank with it. Some hosted builders also fix part of the address for certain page types, such as blog posts or products, so check before you plan your structure.

WordPress lets you change nearly anything, which is both the strength and the risk: one tick in Settings, Reading, “Discourage search engines from indexing this site”, can hide a whole site. It is the first silent failure in the website launch checklist guide, worth reading before your go-live date whichever platform you pick.

On a custom build, nothing exists until someone builds it, including the boring parts like a sitemap and a redirect list, and even whether your text is in the page Google receives. The Kernelpost case study on this site, an illustrative study of a software company whose pages were drawn in the browser by JavaScript, shows how most of a custom site can stay out of Google's index until that is fixed.

What it really costs over three years

Comparing monthly prices is how owners get surprised. The real cost of a platform is the build, plus the monthly plan, plus the apps or plugins you add, plus the help you pay for every year: updates, fixes, the developer who adds a form. A “free” platform with a €400-a-year maintenance contract can cost more than a €30-a-month builder you look after yourself.

Try it on someone else's numbers first. This is an illustrative example with made-up figures: a café gets two quotes. A custom site for €6,000 with €50 a month hosting, or a Wix site set up for €1,200 at €25 a month, with no other help needed for either.

Make a guess

Over three years, how much more does the custom quote cost the café than the Wix one?

€1,000
€0€10,000

Anything within ±€400 counts as right.

Now your own. Prices change often, so take today's figures from each platform's own pricing page rather than from any article, this one included. Shopify, for example, also charges an extra fee on each sale if you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments; check whether that applies in your country.

The calculator below counts four lines. A real quote has more, such as content writing, photos, email and the extras quotes often leave out; the website cost guide, next in this series, takes each one apart.

Run the calculator once for each platform on your shortlist and write both totals down. You will need them in the last section.

Try the numbers

Your three-year cost for one platform

€2,500
€30 a month
€20 a month
€600 a year

Total over three years

€6,100

Average per month

€169 a month

Running costs share

59%

Your own estimate from your own numbers, not a quote. Add payment or transaction fees separately if you sell online. If the running-costs share is above half, the monthly plan and help matter more than the build price: negotiate those first.

Lock-in: the question to ask before you sign up

Every platform makes it easy to arrive. Few make it easy to leave. Before you commit, ask: if I want to move in four years, what comes with me, and what do I rebuild?

Here is the two-minute question promised at the start: whose name is the domain in? Log in to the company your domain is registered with, or ask whoever pays the renewal. Everything else on this page can be rebuilt with money. A domain registered by a former designer, on their account, can take weeks of emails to get back, and until then you cannot point it anywhere.

With WordPress, everything can move: the content exports in a standard format, and any host can run it. With Shopify, products, customers and orders export as spreadsheets, but the theme and many app features do not run anywhere else. Wix's own help centre says a Wix site cannot be exported to another host: you can copy your text and images, but the design and structure are rebuilt. With custom code, it depends entirely on your contract: if the developer owns the code or hosts it on their account, you may own nothing.

So keep the domain out of the lock-in altogether: register it in your business's name, on an account you control, separately from the platform if you can. Then a move changes where the site lives, not where people find it.

What would you do?

A bakery outgrows its builder

This is an illustrative example. A bakery has run a 40-page site on a website builder for five years. Most of its Google traffic comes from recipe and cake pages. It now wants online ordering with delivery slots, which the builder cannot do well, so it plans to move to WordPress.

What should the bakery do first?

Mistakes that make owners switch platforms within two years

Most platform regrets come from a handful of predictable decisions. None is a disaster on its own; together they mean paying for a site twice. Count how many you were about to make. The checklist at the end of this guide is built to catch them before you sign.

  • Choosing because a friend or designer uses it, without checking it does your top two jobs.
  • Picking a builder for a shop that will clearly grow to hundreds of products.
  • Going custom for a six-page service site because it sounded more professional.
  • Installing a plugin or app for every small wish until the site is slow and fragile.
  • Letting the designer register the domain or platform account in their own name.
  • Ignoring a second language until after launch, then discovering the platform handles it badly.
  • Forgetting that someone must apply WordPress updates every month, and nobody is assigned to do it.

Your platform quiz: how much platform do you need?

Answer honestly for the next two to three years, not for an ideal future. The result is a starting point for your shortlist, not a verdict. If you sell physical products online, keep Shopify and WooCommerce on your list whatever the score says.

Score yourself

Eight questions about what your site must handle

  1. The site needs more than one language.

  2. It needs a feature no off-the-shelf platform offers, such as a custom quote or booking rule.

  3. It must connect to other systems: stock, accounting, a CRM or a booking calendar.

  4. You expect more than 50 pages within two years.

  5. You want precise control of URLs, redirects and structured data.

  6. Several people with different permissions will edit it.

  7. You have budget for a developer on call every year.

  8. You will publish new content every week or two, such as articles, recipes or listings.

0 / 16

0 of 8 answered. Answer them all to see your result.

Decide in an afternoon

You do not need weeks of research. You already have the pieces: your list of needs, your result above and the two totals from the calculator. The decision follows a short order. Put the steps in the order that saves you the most rework.

Put it in order

Put the steps of choosing a platform in order

Use the arrows to move each item, then check.

  1. Write the jobs the site must do in the next three years
  2. Run the three-year cost for the ones left
  3. Use lock-in to break a tie between the last two
  4. Cross off platforms that cannot do your top two jobs
  5. Spend an hour in the winner's editor before you sign

Checklist

Before you sign up or sign a contract

0 of 9 done

Saved on this device only

Questions owners ask

Questions people ask

Is WordPress free?

The software is free to download and use. Running it is not: you pay for hosting, usually a theme, often some plugins, and someone's time to keep it all updated.

Should I switch platforms to improve my rankings?

Rarely. If your site ranks badly, the cause is much more often content, speed, local signals or technical mistakes than the platform. Fix those first; a move without careful redirects can make things worse, not better.

Before blaming the platform for being slow, put your homepage and a competitor's through the free speed comparison tool on this site. If theirs is fast on the same platform, the cause is in your setup, usually images, apps or plugins. And if your traffic has dropped suddenly, the traffic drop guide is a calmer first step than a move.

What about Webflow, Squarespace or other platforms?

The same method applies. Write your needs, check the platform does the top two, run the three-year cost and ask what you can export. Webflow, for example, sits between a builder and custom code: more design control, a steeper learning curve.

Does the platform affect showing up in AI answers?

Not directly. AI assistants and Google's AI Overviews draw on pages they can access and understand. Clear, crawlable pages with real information matter far more than the software behind them. One practical check: not every crawler runs JavaScript the way Google does, so make sure your important text is in the page itself, not loaded later by scripts. Open a page, view its source and search for a sentence from it.

The guide on getting your business mentioned by ChatGPT and other AI assistants covers what does matter there.

Once you have a shortlist, the free planner below turns your needs into a structured brief you can send to designers or developers, so every quote answers the same questions and you can compare them fairly.

Then bring your two calculator totals to the next guide in this series, on what a website really costs. It shows what pushes the build price up or down, how to compare quotes line by line, and the bills that arrive after you sign, so you can tell which of your numbers to question before anyone sends an invoice.

You reached the end

Your summary

This guide has 9 quick questions

Try them to see how much you already know. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Start with the first question
Your checklist0 of 9 done
Revisit the section “Decide in an afternoon”

New guides by email when they are published.

Unsubscribe in one click.

What to do next

  1. Write the five jobs your site must do in the next three years, and circle the top two.
  2. Run the three-year cost calculator for your two shortlisted platforms with prices from their own pricing pages.
  3. Check whose name your domain is registered in, and move it to your business's account if it is not yours.
  4. Spend an hour in the editor of your first-choice platform before you sign anything.

Not sure which build fits?

Answer five questions and get a recommended build, add-ons and matching demos.

Open the planner

Planning a website

What a website really costs: the build, the bills and the extras nobody quotes

The cheapest quote is not always the cheapest website. Add up three years, not one invoice, and the answer can flip.

23 min readStart reading

See it on a real build

Every brand in the demos is fictional.

Browse all demo builds