Skip to content

Planning a website · guide 2 of 7

Planning a website redesign: what to keep, what to change

Treat a redesign as an upgrade, not a reset: find the pages that already bring visits, enquiries and links, decide what to keep, merge, rewrite or drop, then design around it.

24 min readUpdated 9 Nov 2026

  • 12 questions to test yourself
  • 1 calculator
  • 8-item checklist
On this page10 sections

The page you hate might be the one paying the bills

Most owners who want a new website can point at the page that embarrasses them most. The clumsy article from years ago. The services page with the stock photo. The price list nobody has touched since it was written.

Here is the uncomfortable part: that page is sometimes the one quietly bringing in the enquiries. It has been on Google for years, other sites link to it, and it answers a question people really type. Delete it in a fresh start and you can lose something you never knew you had.

By the end you will have a page-by-page plan: what to keep, merge, rewrite or drop, what to write before the designer starts, and what to put in writing so Google visits survive the switch. Later we will also come to the one setting that can hide a brand-new site from Google on launch day, and the two-minute check that catches it.

First, a guess about a site that is not yours.

Quick quiz

An illustrative example: a made-up plumbing firm has a homepage, five service pages and one 2016 blog post called “Why is my boiler losing pressure?”. Which page is most likely to bring the most first-time visitors from Google?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Name the real problem before you redesign

“The site looks old” is a feeling, not a problem. A redesign is expensive, so it should fix something you can name and, ideally, measure: too few enquiries, a form that fails on phones, prices nobody can find, a platform you cannot edit yourself.

Write the problem down in one sentence before you talk to anyone about design. “Visitors on phones cannot book” leads to a very different project than “we want to look more premium”. Some problems are not solved by a redesign at all, and finding that out now saves the budget for the fix that works.

Myth or fact?

Symptom check: will a redesign fix it?

For each one: myth or fact?0 of 5 answered
  1. 1.My site looks dated, so Google ranks it lower, and a new design will fix my rankings.

  2. 2.Most of my visitors are on phones and the booking form is hard to use there. Rebuilding the templates is a real fix.

  3. 3.Hardly anyone visits the site. A redesign will bring more visitors.

  4. 4.I cannot change prices or opening hours without paying a developer every time. Moving to an editable platform is a fair reason to rebuild.

  5. 5.Plenty of people visit, but almost nobody gets in touch. A redesign will definitely fix this.

Audit what works: traffic, enquiries and links

Before anyone sketches a new layout, list every page on the current site and add three columns: visits from Google, enquiries, and links from other sites. For a small business, an afternoon with free tools is usually enough.

One number decides how urgent the first step is. Guess it.

Make a guess

How many months of search data does Google Search Console keep for your site?

6 months
1 months36 months

Anything within ±2 months counts as right.

Step by step

The afternoon audit, one column at a time

Step 1 of 4

Visits from Google

In Google Search Console, open Performance, choose the longest date range and switch to the Pages tab. Sort by clicks and export.

The top 10 or 20 pages are the ones you must not break. Mark them in bold in your spreadsheet.

Now put a rough value on what you found. Add up the monthly Google clicks of your top pages from the export (or take the total from the Pages tab for the last 28 days) and try your own numbers.

Try the numbers

What are your top pages worth to you?

750 visits
2%
€100

Enquiries a month from these pages

15 enquiries

What a month without them would cost

€1,500

What they bring in over a year

€18,000

Your own rough estimate from your own numbers, not a forecast. Use it as a yardstick: if a proper page-by-page redirect map costs less than one month in the middle line, it is an easy yes. Keep this figure for the conversation with your developer in a later section.

Keep, merge, rewrite or drop: a decision for every page

With the numbers in front of you, every page gets one of four labels. Write the label in your spreadsheet next to the page address; this list becomes the backbone of the whole project.

  • Keep: the page brings visits, enquiries or links and still says the right thing. Move it across with the same address and the same core text, in the new design.
  • Merge: two or more weak pages cover the same thing (“plumber Sofia” and “plumbing services Sofia”). Combine them into one stronger page and redirect the old addresses to it.
  • Rewrite: the page gets visits but is out of date, thin or unclear. Keep the address and the topic, improve the content. Change carefully: keep the words people search for.
  • Drop: no visits, no links, no enquiries, and nothing a customer needs. Remove it, and redirect it to the closest relevant page if anything ever linked to it.

Test yourself

Six illustrative pages: label each one before you flip

Think of your answer, then flip the card.0 of 6 flipped

Content first, design second

The most common redesign mistake is designing empty boxes. A designer draws a beautiful homepage with a three-word headline and four neat tiles, and then your real text does not fit, or the tiles have nothing to say.

Turn it round. Decide the pages (from your keep, merge, rewrite, drop list), then write or update the text for the important ones, then let the design serve that text. A designer who sees real content makes better choices about layout, and you avoid weeks of waiting at the end for words that should have come first.

Start with the homepage text. It is the page most visitors judge first, and the hardest to fit into a design drawn without it. The next guide in this series, on the homepage that turns visitors into enquiries, shows what its first screen has to say.

Before and after

The same project, two orders

Design first

Week 1: mood boards and homepage design. Week 4: design approved. Week 6: “Can you send the text?” Week 10: still waiting for the services pages. The old blog posts are forgotten. Launch slips, and three pages that ranked are missing.

Content first

Week 1: page audit and keep, merge, rewrite, drop list. Weeks 2–3: text for the key pages, with the ranking pages carried across. Week 4: design built around real words. Launch on the planned date, with every important page and address in place.

  • This is an illustrative example, not a promise of timing: the point is the order of work.
  • Content written first shapes the design, instead of being squeezed into it.
  • The pages that bring visits are decided in week 1, so they cannot be forgotten at the end.

Put it in order

Put the stages of a redesign in a sensible order

Use the arrows to move each item, then check.

  1. Name the problem the redesign must fix
  2. Set up redirects, test and launch
  3. Write and update the content
  4. Label each page keep, merge, rewrite or drop
  5. Design and build around that content
  6. Audit pages for visits, enquiries and links

SEO protections: what to insist on before work starts

Google ranks pages, and each page's history is tied to its exact address. If the new site changes addresses (new platform, new structure, new domain), the redesign is also a migration and needs the same care. The guide on moving or redesigning a site without losing your Google traffic covers it step by step, including how to build the redirect map. If you can keep the same addresses, do: the safest redirect is the one you never need. If you cannot, here is the conversation most owners end up having with their developer.

What would you do?

The developer's shortcut

An illustrative example: a made-up bakery is moving to a new platform, and every page address will change. Two weeks before launch the developer writes: “To keep it simple, we will redirect all the old pages to the new homepage.”

What do you reply?

Checklist

Ask for these in writing before work starts

0 of 8 done

Saved on this device only

Launch day: the setting that can hide your whole new site

This is the setting promised at the start. Test versions of new sites are usually told “do not index” so Google ignores them while they are unfinished. The trouble starts when nobody switches it off.

Before the answer, a puzzle.

Quick quiz

An illustrative example: a made-up dental clinic relaunches its redesigned site on the same domain. It looks perfect in the browser, but over the next week its pages drop out of Google, even for its own name. What is the most likely cause?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

The noindex setting is the loudest launch mistake, not the only one. Lost email, forms that send to nobody and a speed test on the wrong page are quieter. The website launch checklist guide takes you through them in the order they happen, from three weeks before go-live to week eight.

Budget and timeline realism

Redesigns run late for boring reasons: content arrives late, decisions wait for one busy person, and new ideas get added halfway through. Fewer run late because the code was hard.

Plan for three things that quotes often leave out: time to write or update content (yours, or paid), time to set up and test redirects, and a small budget for fixes in the first weeks after launch. What a site costs at each level is covered in the website cost guide; the planner at the end of this one helps you scope yours.

Timeline

An illustrative timeline for a 10–20 page small-business site

  1. Weeks 1–2

    Problem and audit

    Write down the problem, export the Search Console and analytics numbers, label every page.

  2. Weeks 2–4

    Content

    Write and update text for the key pages, gather photos, agree the page list and the redirect map.

  3. Weeks 4–8

    Design and build

    Design around the real content, build on the test site, enter the pages.

  4. Weeks 8–9

    Test and launch

    Check every redirect, the forms on a phone, the “do not index” setting. Launch early in the week, not before a holiday.

  5. Weeks 9–17

    Watch and fix

    Check Search Console weekly for errors and pages that dropped. Fix quickly while the details are fresh.

What would you do?

Six weeks in, a new idea

An illustrative example: a made-up physiotherapy clinic is halfway through its redesign. The owner sees a competitor's site with an online booking system and a blog, and wants both added before launch.

What is the best move?

Measuring success after launch

Go back to the sentence you wrote at the start. If the problem was “people on phones cannot book”, success is more bookings from phones, not a nicer homepage. Measure the thing you set out to fix.

Compare like with like. Many businesses are seasonal, so compare the weeks after launch with the same weeks last year as well as with the weeks just before. And give it time: a fair read usually needs a couple of months, not a couple of days.

Quick quiz

An illustrative example: two weeks after launch, a made-up accountancy firm sees Google clicks down compared with the month before. What should it do first?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

If the fall is wider than a few pages, or the redirects all check out, work through the causes in order rather than guessing. The calm diagnosis checklist for a Google traffic drop starts with the two-minute check that ends many scares: is the drop real, and is it just the season?

Are you ready to start the redesign?

Score yourself honestly. Each “No” is a question that would otherwise come up in the middle of the project, when it costs the most to answer. Your result tells you what to do this week.

Score yourself

Redesign readiness, point by point

  1. I can name the problem the redesign must fix in one sentence

  2. I know my top 10 pages by Google clicks

  3. I know which pages lead to enquiries

  4. I know which pages other sites link to

  5. Every page has a keep, merge, rewrite or drop label

  6. Text for the key pages is written or assigned to someone

  7. My developer has agreed to a redirect map in writing

  8. I have a “before” snapshot to compare against after launch

0 / 16

0 of 8 answered. Answer them all to see your result.

Where to go from here depends on your project, and all of these are linked just below.

  • Your page addresses will change: read the site migration guide before you sign off the quote.
  • You are still choosing what to build on: the platform guide compares WordPress, Shopify, Wix and custom builds.
  • Your budget is not set yet: the website cost guide breaks a quote into its parts, including the ones quotes leave out.
  • Your homepage is the page you most want to fix: the next guide in this series starts there.

You reached the end

Your summary

This guide has 12 quick questions

Try them to see how much you already know. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Start with the first question

New guides by email when they are published.

Unsubscribe in one click.

What to do next

  1. Write one sentence naming the problem your redesign must fix, and how you will measure it.
  2. Open Search Console, Performance, Pages, set the longest date range and export your top 20 pages by clicks.
  3. Label every page keep, merge, rewrite or drop in a spreadsheet before you speak to a designer.
  4. Ask any developer you are considering to commit to a one-to-one redirect map in writing.

Not sure which build fits?

Answer five questions and get a recommended build, add-ons and matching demos.

Open the planner

Planning a website

The homepage that turns visitors into enquiries

Can a stranger tell what you do, where, and how to start, before they scroll? Many homepages fail that test, and their owners never find out.

27 min readStart reading

See it on a real build

Every brand in the demos is fictional.

Browse all demo builds