Skip to content

Local SEO · guide 5 of 7

Citations and NAP consistency: which listings matter and how to clean them up

Your name, address and phone are listed on sites you have never visited. Which listings matter, how to find the wrong ones, fix them in the right order and keep them clean in 20 minutes a quarter.

23 min readUpdated 9 Nov 2026

  • 8 questions to test yourself
  • 1 calculator
  • 16-item checklist
On this page11 sections

The customer who called your old number and gave up

A customer finds you in a directory you forgot existed. The listing shows the phone number you dropped two years ago. They call, hear “this number is not in service”, and ring the next business on the list. You never learn they existed.

Every place your business name, address and phone number appear online is a citation. Most were created without you: copied from an old website, scraped from another directory, or added by a helpful customer. Some are wrong, and the wrong ones cost you before any question of Google rankings comes up.

By the end you will have one master record of your details, a short list of the listings worth your time, a cleanup order and a 20-minute quarterly routine. Along the way, two things most owners never hear about: the free listing that controls what iPhone users see, and the habit that makes fixed listings turn wrong again a month later.

First, a test of your eye.

Quick quiz

Four listings for the same bakery each differ from its website in one way. Which difference is most likely to cost it customers?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

What a citation is, in one minute

NAP stands for name, address and phone number. A citation is any mention of those details outside your own website. Local marketers split them into two kinds.

Structured citations are listings with fields: your Google Business Profile, Apple Maps, Bing Places, Facebook, Yelp, a chamber of commerce directory, a trade association’s member list. Unstructured citations are mentions in running text: a local news story, a blog post about the best coffee in town, a supplier’s “where to buy” page.

Many local marketers extend NAP to NAP+W, adding your website address, and in practice also your opening hours and categories. Those are the details people act on, so they are the details worth keeping right.

Unstructured mentions matter beyond maps, too. They are part of how search engines and AI assistants piece together who you are, which is what the guide “Becoming a known brand to Google and AI” is about. This guide stays with the listings, where wrong details do the most direct damage.

Test yourself

Think of your answer, then flip the card.0 of 4 flipped

Do citations help you rank? What is known and what is guessed

Owners hear a lot of confident claims about listings. Before the evidence, sort four of them into myth or fact. Your instincts are probably better than the sales emails.

Myth or fact?

Four things owners are told about citations

For each one: myth or fact?0 of 4 answered
  1. 1.More citations always means better local rankings.

  2. 2.Google can change your profile using information from other sources.

  3. 3.“St.” on one site and “Street” on another will hurt you.

  4. 4.A duplicate profile for your business on Google is worth removing.

Be wary of anyone who answers this with a percentage. Google’s help page “Tips to improve your local ranking on Google” says local results rest on relevance, distance and prominence, and that prominence includes information Google has about a business from across the web, such as links, articles and directories. That is the whole official statement; the guide “The map pack” explains what each of the three means for you. Google does not publish “NAP consistency” as a ranking factor or say how much a directory listing weighs.

The rest comes from practitioners. Whitespark’s Local Search Ranking Factors survey, which asks local SEO specialists for their opinions, has for years rated citations as a smaller factor than the Google Business Profile itself, reviews and the website. Treat that as experienced opinion, not measurement.

So the honest case for cleanup is narrower than many sellers claim, and stronger. A few important listings, correct everywhere they appear, remove a reason for Google and for customers to doubt which details are true. Hundreds of extra listings on obscure sites do not.

Which listings matter: the short list

You do not need 200 listings. You need the handful that real customers use, correct, and then the ones that are specific to your trade and town. Work down this table and stop when the sites stop being ones your customers would plausibly use.

Here is the free listing promised at the start. Apple Business Connect is Apple’s free tool for managing how you appear in Apple Maps and Siri, the default maps on every iPhone. If you have never claimed your place there, Apple shows whatever it gathered from other sources, and nobody on your side checks it. Bing Places for Business, the other surprise, can import your Google Business Profile, which makes it a short job once your Google details are right.

Side by side

ListingWhy it mattersPriority
Your websiteThe source every listing should match; many directories copy itFirst, always
Google Business ProfileGoogle Search and Maps: the listing local customers see mostFirst, always
Apple Business ConnectFree control of Apple Maps and Siri on iPhonesHigh
Bing Places for BusinessFeeds Bing and services that use it; imports your Google profileHigh
Facebook and Instagram pagesWhere many people check hours and message youHigh if you have them
Your industry’s main sitesWhere customers compare: Tripadvisor for restaurants, booking apps for salonsHigh for your trade
Local and national directoriesChamber of commerce, trade body, the main national directoryMedium
Data aggregators (mainly US)Data Axle, Localeze, Foursquare: they feed many smaller sitesMedium in the US, low elsewhere
Directories nobody usesCreated to sell listings; no visitors, thousands of unrelated categoriesSkip
Which industry and national sites matter depends on your country and trade. The test is simple: would a real customer use this site to find a business like yours?

Write your master record before you touch a single listing

Most cleanups fail the same way: the owner fixes 15 listings, each slightly differently, and creates a new inconsistency. Before you log in anywhere, write down the exact version of every detail, once, and copy and paste it from then on.

Use the name you use on your sign, your receipts and your website. Google’s guidelines for the business name say to use your real-world name and not to add keywords, locations or slogans, and the same advice keeps every other listing clean. Settle your main category before it goes in the record: our Google Business Profile guide shows how to choose it.

Before and after

One business, two ways of keeping its details

In your head

Name: Rosa’s, Bakery Rosa, or Rosa Bakery Ltd, depending on who typed it.

Phone: whichever number was on the last flyer.

Hours: “we open around 7”.

Master record

Written once, pasted everywhere

Name: Bakery Rosa. Address: 12 Vitosha Boulevard, 1000 Sofia. Phone: +359 2 123 4567. Website: the home page address, starting with https.

Hours: Mon–Sat 07:00–19:00, Sun closed. Main category: Bakery. Short description: two sentences, written once.

Old details to hunt for: the previous phone number, the address before the move, the old business name.

  • The last line is the one most people skip, and the one that makes the search in the next section work. Your old details are the search terms that find your wrong listings.
  • The example bakery is made up, but the structure fits any business.
  • Tick each line below as you write it in a note or spreadsheet. Ten minutes now saves pasting three versions of your name later.

Checklist

Write your master record now

0 of 8 done

Saved on this device only

Find every listing out there with free searches

You are looking for two things: listings with old or wrong details, and duplicates. Your master record’s last line, the old details, is now your search list. Work through these steps with a spreadsheet open.

Step by step

The search, one step at a time

Step 1 of 5

Search the old phone number

Put it in quotes, in national and international format, such as “02 987 6543” and “+359 2 987 6543”. Every result showing it is a listing to fix or a page whose owner you can ask to update.

Paid tools from companies such as BrightLocal, Whitespark, Moz and Yext can scan many directories at once, which saves real time with several locations. For a single shop, the searches above usually find the listings that matter. Now put your own numbers in.

Try the numbers

How much time will your cleanup take?

15 listings
6 listings
20 min
€30

Hands-on time to fix the wrong ones

2 hours

Your time, at your own hourly value

€60

One-hour sessions to block in your calendar

2 sessions

Your own estimate, not a quote. Compare the middle figure with any price you are quoted for a listing service: if the quote is higher and covers sites your customers do not use, do it yourself; if your hours are scarce, paying can be sensible, but no service can fix a duplicate Google pin for you. Some sites need a verification call or postcard, so calendar time is longer than hands-on time.

Cleanup, in the order that stops wrong data coming back

Here is the habit promised at the start. Almost every owner fixes the listing in front of them first: the small directory that showed the old number. A month later it is wrong again, because it refreshed from the source it copied, or because that source fed the old details back into Google as a “Google update”.

Listings copy each other, so start at the sources and work outwards. Try putting the steps in order before reading the explanation.

Put it in order

Put the cleanup steps in the order that saves the most rework

Use the arrows to move each item, then check.

  1. Correct Apple, Bing, Facebook and your industry’s main sites
  2. Write the master record, including old details to hunt for
  3. Correct your own website, including the footer and contact page
  4. Correct your Google Business Profile and remove any duplicates
  5. Ask smaller directories and other sites to update or remove old details

While you are on step two, make your website easy to copy correctly. Put the name, address and phone in the footer and on the contact page as text, not only inside an image, written exactly as in your master record.

You can also state the same details in LocalBusiness markup, code that labels them as name, address, phone and hours for machines. The free schema markup generator linked at the end of this guide turns your master record into that code to paste into your site, and our schema markup guide explains what it does and does not do. It removes guesswork about your details; it does not guarantee anything about rankings.

Step by step

Fixing a listing you do not control

Step 1 of 4

Look for a claim button

Most directories have “Claim this business” or “Is this your business?”. Claiming usually means confirming by phone, email or a code, and then you can edit directly.

Duplicates, moves and closed locations

These cases cause the worst confusion, because a customer can find two versions of you and pick the wrong one.

If you moved, edit the address on your existing Google profile rather than creating a new one, so you keep your reviews. For a duplicate profile on Google Maps, open it, choose to suggest an edit and report that it is a duplicate or that the place has moved, or ask Google Business Profile support. On other sites, ask for the old listing to be merged or removed, not left beside the new one.

If you closed one of several locations, mark it as permanently closed on Google rather than deleting it, and do the same on the other important sites. A listing that says closed tells customers where not to go; a missing one leaves them guessing.

To see a bigger version of this mess untangled, read the Ironvale Auto Glass case study on this site. It is illustrative (an invented 20-van windshield repair firm in Phoenix): old franchise-era addresses had left it with nine Google profiles, and the study follows the duplicates being dealt with one by one before the wider citation cleanup. Its figures are modelled, not a client result.

What would you do?

A physiotherapy clinic moves across town

This is an illustrative example. The clinic moved six months ago. Its Google profile was updated, but searching its old address turns up 9 listings, including a second Google Maps pin at the old address with 11 reviews.

What should the owner do first?

Mistakes that cost time or money

Three habits cause most self-inflicted citation problems, plus one trap with call tracking.

  • Adding keywords to your name on listings, such as “Bakery Rosa Best Cakes Sofia”. Google’s guidelines prohibit it on your profile, and it makes every other listing inconsistent with your sign.
  • Paying for listings on directories that sell placements by the hundred. If no customer uses the site, the listing is not worth money.
  • Buying a subscription listing service without asking what happens when you cancel. With some services the listings stay correct only while you pay; ask for that answer in writing.

Quick quiz

You want to know how many calls come from your Google profile. Which set-up keeps your listings consistent?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Keeping it clean: 20 minutes a quarter

Listings drift. A customer suggests an edit, a directory refreshes from an old source, Google applies an update from somewhere else. A short routine catches it before customers do.

Whenever something changes, such as a new number, new hours or a move, update your master record first, then work through the same order as the cleanup. Holiday hours are the change people forget most; add them to your Google profile ahead of time.

Score yourself first, then use the checklist as the routine. When a quarterly check finds nothing to fix, that is the result you want, not wasted time: a customer who finds you anywhere can reach you.

Score yourself

Your listings, scored: where to start tomorrow

  1. I have one written master record of my name, address, phone, website and hours

  2. My website shows exactly the same details

  3. My Google Business Profile matches the master record

  4. There is only one Google Maps listing for my business

  5. Searching my old phone number finds no live listings

  6. Apple Maps and Bing show the right details

  7. I know which directories in my trade customers actually use

0 / 14

0 of 7 answered. Answer them all to see your result.

Checklist

Your quarterly listing check

0 of 8 done

Saved on this device only

Questions owners ask

Questions people ask

Do I have to match the address format exactly on every site?

No. Different sites format addresses differently, and abbreviations do not confuse search engines. What must match is the substance: the same street, number, postcode and unit.

I work from home and serve customers at their place. What do I list?

Google lets service-area businesses hide their address and show the areas they serve instead. Keep the name and phone consistent everywhere, and only show an address where you actually receive customers. The guide “SEO for service-area businesses” covers this in detail, including what to do if your pin already shows your home.

Should I pay for a listing management service?

For one location, usually not: the free searches and the important sites take an afternoon. With many locations, a tool can save real time. Either way, check which sites it covers and what happens to your listings if you stop paying.

Someone keeps changing my Google listing back to the old details. Why?

Google may update profiles from other sources and user suggestions. If wrong details keep returning, they are probably still live somewhere prominent. Search the old details again, fix the source, and reject the change in your profile.

My listings are clean. What should I work on next?

Reviews, then your map pack visibility. The next guide in this series, on Google reviews, covers how to get more of them, reply well and handle the bad ones. The guide “The map pack” then shows how your profile, reviews and website work together in the top three local results.

You reached the end

Your summary

This guide has 8 quick questions

Try them to see how much you already know. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Start with the first question

New guides by email when they are published.

Unsubscribe in one click.

What to do next

  1. Write your master record today, ending with your old phone number, old address and any former business name.
  2. Search your old phone number in quotes, in national and international format, and log every result in a tracker.
  3. Fix your website first (the free schema generator turns your master record into LocalBusiness code), then your Google profile, Apple Business Connect, Bing Places and your trade’s main site.
  4. Put the quarterly listing check in your calendar, starting with the “Google updates” on your profile.

Generate your schema markup

Fill in a short form and get ready-to-paste JSON-LD for a local business, a product or an FAQ page.

Open the generator

Local SEO

Google reviews: how to get more, reply well and handle the bad ones

Eight reviews against a competitor's 140, or one one-star review you keep rereading? Here is the system that fixes both, without breaking Google's rules.

28 min readStart reading

See it applied in an illustrative case study

Invented businesses and modelled figures, not client results: how the work in this guide fits into a whole engagement.

See all 95 studies