Fake listings
11
suspect listings within 5 km of the yard
Eleven “24/7 emergency” profiles pinned to a car park, a PO box and two private houses, all routed to one call-tracking network that sells the lead to whoever bids.
Reading 1 of 4
A fictional business. The figures are a modelled scenario, not a client result.
Meter reading · Local SEO
Gullyfoot Plumbing · Emergency plumbing & heating, 12 vans · Swansea
+354% calls from the map listing
Swansea, Wales · UK & Ireland · Local services · 8 months · Local plan
Calls a month from the map listing, month 8236
up from 52 in month 0
How to read the meter: the odometer counts phone calls that came from the Google listing in one month. The two red dials are the map-pack rank and the star rating. Modelled data.
01The problem
Fake competitor listings and an outdated phone number pushed a 24-hour Swansea plumber out of the map pack for “emergency plumber”.
When a pipe bursts at 2 am, nobody scrolls. They search “emergency plumber”, tap the first Call button in the map pack and hope. By the winter Gullyfoot was not in that pack. Three listings with no premises, no vans and keyword-stuffed names held the top places, and the number on Gullyfoot’s own profile went to an office line that rang out after six.
Nothing was wrong with the plumbing. Everything was wrong with the profile hygiene.
02The audit
We walked the line from the search result to the van, the way a plumber traces a drip back to the joint.
Fake listings
11
suspect listings within 5 km of the yard
Eleven “24/7 emergency” profiles pinned to a car park, a PO box and two private houses, all routed to one call-tracking network that sells the lead to whoever bids.
Reading 1 of 4
Phone number
64
citations still showing the old number
The firm moved to a 24-hour line last year. The profile, the website footer and the directories never caught up, so night-time calls reached a line nobody answered.
Reading 2 of 4
Opening hours
14
hours a day shown as “Closed”
The profile said Monday to Friday, 8 to 6. For a 24-hour firm, every “open now” search after six was answered with somebody else.
Reading 3 of 4
Reviews
41
reviews in nine years of trading
A 4.1 average, no replies, and the newest review fourteen months old. Next to it, the fake listings with a handful of perfect scores looked busier.
Reading 4 of 4
03The fix
The work ran on our Local plan: local profile hygiene, done by hand and backed by evidence. No fake reviews, no keyword-stuffed name, no virtual offices.
Each suspect listing was documented with street-level photos, company-register searches and test calls, then reported through Google’s redress form with the evidence attached. Removal is Google’s decision, never guaranteed: nine of eleven came down.
+58 calls a month
One number everywhere. The 24-hour line went onto the profile, the website’s schema and footer, and 64 directory and aggregator citations, each checked by hand. The old office line now forwards around the clock.
+54 calls a month
Open 24 hours on the profile, bank-holiday hours set a month ahead, “Emergency plumber” as the primary category, and a service area drawn to where the vans actually go.
+36 calls a month
A text after every finished job with a direct review link, sent by the engineer who did the work. Every review answered within two days, good or bad. Nothing incentivised, nothing filtered.
+36 calls a month
04The meter
Calls flow from Google search on the left to Gullyfoot’s phones on the right. Each joint on the pipe is a leak where emergency callers slipped away. Seal them in any order: the odometer rolls up to the calls a month that reach the vans, with this study’s modelled figures.
Meter reading
52 calls a month
Still leaking away: 184 calls a month
Leak 1 · Fake listings
Tap a valve to seal its leak. Arrow keys move between valves.
52 calls a month. Map-pack rank #11. 0 of 4 leaks sealed.
05Month by month
Month 161 calls
Test calls at 2 am, a 7×7 rank grid across Swansea, every citation pulled. The 24-hour number goes onto the profile on day three; hours fixed the same week.
Sealed: Wrong number and “Closed” at night
Month 288 calls
Street-level photos and company searches for all eleven suspect listings. The first redress reports go in; the website gets LocalBusiness schema with the new number.
Month 3112 calls
Six fake listings removed in a fortnight. Gullyfoot climbs to #6 for the head term.
Sealed: Fake listings
Month 4139 calls
The last of the 64 citations corrected, from the national aggregators down to a parish newsletter’s trade list.
Month 5168 calls
Three more listings come down after second reports with fresh evidence. Two survive and stay on watch.
Month 6191 calls
Engineers start sending the after-job text. Thirty-eight new reviews in the first month, every one answered.
Sealed: Thin reviews
Month 7214 calls
The first hard frost: burst-pipe searches triple overnight and Gullyfoot holds #2 across most of the grid.
Month 8236 calls
236 calls a month from the listing, 168 reviews at 4.8, and two suspect listings still on watch.
06The reading
Calls a month from the map listing
52 → 236
Taps on the profile’s Call button plus its tracked number, month 8 against month 0.
Map-pack rank, “emergency plumber swansea”
#11 → #2
Median map-pack rank on a 7×7 grid scan across Swansea.
Fake listings removed after reports
9 of 11
Removal is Google’s decision; the two left standing are reported again whenever they change.
Citations with the old number
64 → 0
Profile, website and every directory now show 01632 960247.
Reviews 41 → 168 · rating 4.1 → 4.8 · every review answered
Modelled scenario for a fictional business — not a client result. Rankings and traffic are never guaranteed; see our Terms.
| Query, as searched in Swansea | Month 0 | Month 8 |
|---|---|---|
| emergency plumber swansea | #11 | #2 |
| 24 hour plumber swansea | #12 | #2 |
| burst pipe swansea | #13 | #1 |
| plumber near me | #14 | #3 |
| boiler repair swansea | #9 | #3 |
| blocked drain swansea | #8 | #4 |
Median position across a 7×7 grid of search points over the city. Rankings move daily and are never guaranteed.
Our Local plan traces every leak between a local search and your phone, and seals it by hand.