Skip to content

AI search · guide 4 of 6

Using AI to write content safely: what Google actually cares about

Google does not punish pages for being written with AI. It holds back pages that add nothing. Here is the line, a workflow that stays on the right side of it, and the part only you can write.

26 min readUpdated 9 Nov 2026

  • 11 questions to test yourself
  • 1 calculator
  • 12-item checklist
On this page11 sections

Google does not ask who wrote it. It asks a harder question

You can write a decent service page with an AI tool in four minutes. So can every one of your competitors. If that page is now cheap for everyone, why would Google show yours instead of theirs?

That is the real question behind “Will Google penalise AI content?”, and the answer is more useful than yes or no. Google’s published position is that it rewards helpful, original content however it is produced, and acts against content made mainly to game rankings, whoever or whatever wrote it.

Here is what you get by the end: where Google draws the line, a six-step workflow you can use tomorrow, and a 60-second rewrite that answers the four-minute question above. We will also come back to the one AI habit that is a problem even if Google never looks at your page. Hint: it has nothing to do with rankings.

First, a warm-up. Five things people say about AI and Google: which are true?

Myth or fact?

Five things people believe about AI and Google

For each one: myth or fact?0 of 5 answered
  1. 1.Google demotes pages because they were written by AI.

  2. 2.Pages written entirely by humans can break the same spam policy that catches mass AI content.

  3. 3.You must put an “AI-generated” label on every page or Google will push it down.

  4. 4.Publishing thousands of machine-translated or reworded pages nobody checked can count as spam.

  5. 5.If an AI detector says your text looks human, Google will treat it as human.

What Google has actually said, in plain words

Google’s view has moved. In 2022, Google’s John Mueller described text from AI writing tools as automatically generated content under the guidelines of the time. In February 2023 Google published its guidance on AI-generated content and shifted the focus to the quality of content, not how it is produced. That is still its position.

The same guidance points to a simple self-check from Google’s page “Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content”: think about Who made it, How it was made and Why it exists. Who: is it clear who is behind the page, with a byline where readers would expect one? How: would a reader want to know if automation was involved? Why: is the page there mainly to help people, or mainly to attract search visits?

That page also lists questions Google suggests you ask yourself. One of them is pointed: are you using extensive automation to produce content on many topics? Another asks whether the content provides original information, reporting, research or analysis. Hold on to that second question. It is the one this whole guide is about.

Quick quiz

Which reason for publishing a page is the one Google’s “Why” question warns about?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Scaled content abuse: the one line you must not cross

In March 2024 Google rolled out a core update together with new spam policies. One of them, scaled content abuse, built on the older rule about automatically generated spam and widened it: it covers generating many pages mainly to manipulate rankings and not to help users, whether a machine, people or both made them.

The examples in Google’s spam policies are worth reading slowly, because each one is something an AI tool makes easy: generating many pages with generative AI without adding value for users; scraping or rewording other content, including by synonymising or translating; stitching together content from different pages without adding value; spreading the pages across several sites to hide the volume; and pages stuffed with search phrases that make little sense to a reader.

Breaking these policies can mean lower rankings, pages dropped from results or a manual action, which you would see in Search Console under Security & Manual Actions. Recovery means removing or fixing the pages and asking for a review, and it takes time; our guide to Google penalties walks through that reconsideration request. The cheapest fix is never needing one.

Make a guess

After its March 2024 core update, Google reported how much less low-quality, unoriginal content people were seeing in its results. What figure did it give?

10% less
0% less100% less

Anything within ±10% less counts as right.

What would you do?

A plumber with a big idea (an illustrative example)

A plumbing firm works in 12 towns around its base. A marketing tool offers to write 300 “Plumber in [town]” pages with AI, one for every town within 80 km, for €99. Each page would be the same text with the town name swapped in.

The owner asks you what to do.

What would you advise?

If town or service pages are your own temptation, you do not have to give up on them. The guide on location and service pages that are not copy-paste spam, in our local SEO series, has a 10-second test for whether a page has real local substance and a way to work out how many pages you actually need.

To see that decision made town by town, read the Tofali Homes case study on this site, an illustrative study of an invented home builder around Kisumu: ten towns surveyed, six pages earned with real jobs, and two tempting towns refused because the firm had no work there.

Why a raw AI draft struggles, even when it is not spam

Most AI content on small-business sites is not spam. It is just forgettable. A language model writes by predicting likely words from what it has seen, so its first draft tends to sound like the average of everything already published on the topic.

That is a problem for one specific reason. If the top results already say it, a page that says it again in different words gives Google little reason to prefer it and gives a reader little reason to stay. Google’s question about original information, reporting, research or analysis is aimed exactly at this gap.

The good news: the gap is easy for a real business to fill, because you have the one input no model has. You have done the work. Here is how the jobs split, and the right-hand column is where your page wins or loses.

Side by side

Part of the pageAn AI draft gives youOnly you can add
StructureA sensible outline and headings in secondsWhich questions your customers really ask first
FactsPlausible facts, some of them wrongFacts you have checked, and your own prices and terms
ExamplesGeneric examples anyone could writeReal jobs, real mistakes, real before-and-after photos
OpinionsBalanced, careful, rarely a firm viewWhat you recommend, and when you would turn a job down
Local detailLittle or none, or inventedStreets, seasons, local rules and suppliers you deal with
AccountabilityNone: a tool cannot stand behind a claimA named person who answers for what the page says
AI is a fast assistant for the left column. The right column is what makes a page worth ranking.

Most small businesses sit on the right-hand column without using it. The Vygie Pest Control case study on this site, an illustrative study of an invented Durban pest-control firm, starts exactly there: thirty technicians’ worth of answers to the questions customers ask every summer, and service pages that were the same text with a different pest name. The rest of this guide is about getting that knowledge onto the page.

Build a workflow that keeps a human in charge

The safest way to use AI is not a list of banned uses. It is an order of work in which the human input goes in first and the human check comes last. Get the order wrong and you end up decorating a generic draft instead of building a useful page.

Try putting these six steps in the order that works.

Put it in order

Put the steps of a safe AI-assisted page in order

Use the arrows to move each item, then check.

  1. A named person reads it in full, approves it and publishes
  2. Write your own raw notes: jobs, numbers, opinions, photos
  3. Check every fact, number, name and claim against a source
  4. Rewrite in your voice and add the experience only you have
  5. Decide who the page is for and the one question it must answer
  6. Ask the AI for an outline or a draft built from your notes

Fact-checking: where AI drafts go wrong

AI tools can state false things in a confident, fluent sentence. These errors are often called hallucinations, and they are hardest to spot exactly where they do the most damage: numbers, names, quotes and rules.

Two real cases show why “the tool wrote it” is no defence. In 2023, lawyers in the New York case Mata v. Avianca were sanctioned after filing a brief that cited court cases ChatGPT had invented. In 2024, a Canadian tribunal ruled in Moffatt v. Air Canada that the airline had to honour wrong advice about a bereavement fare discount that its website chatbot gave a customer. What your site says, you own.

You do not need to check every word with the same care. Flip the cards to see the claims that deserve the most suspicion and what to do with each.

Test yourself

Think of your answer, then flip the card.0 of 6 flipped

Adding experience: the part only you can write

Experience is the first E in E-E-A-T, the qualities Google’s guidance and its search quality rater guidelines describe. It means showing you have actually done the thing: used the product, fixed the fault, visited the place. A model cannot supply it, because it has not done anything. Our guide E-E-A-T explained, in the content series, covers all four letters; here we only need the first.

This is the answer to the question from the start: why Google would show your page instead of a competitor’s identical four-minute draft. Test your eye first. The sentences below are made up for illustration.

Quick quiz

Four sentences from boiler service pages. Which one could an AI tool not have written from a blank prompt?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Before and after

A boiler service page, before and after (illustrative)

Raw AI draft

Regular boiler servicing is essential to ensure your system runs efficiently and safely. Our experienced team provides comprehensive servicing to keep your home warm and comfortable all year round. Contact us today for a free quote.

With experience added

Most of the breakdowns we are called to in October are boilers that were last serviced two or more winters ago. A service with us takes 45 to 60 minutes and costs €85. We check the flue, the pressure and the seals, and we send you photos of the readings before we leave. If your boiler is over 15 years old, we will tell you honestly whether servicing it is still worth the money.

  • A pattern only someone doing the job would notice (October breakdowns, skipped services).
  • Real numbers the reader can act on: duration and price.
  • Proof the reader can see: photos of the readings.
  • An honest opinion that might lose a sale today, which is exactly what makes it believable. The rewrite took about 60 seconds of the owner’s knowledge, not 60 minutes of writing.

Stuck for details? Pick one page you want to write, answer these questions out loud, and paste the answers into your notes before you prompt. Tick each one as you go: every answer is something no competitor’s AI tool can produce.

Checklist

Your notes before you prompt

0 of 5 done

Saved on this device only

How much human time does this really need?

AI saves typing time, not thinking time. The honest way to plan is to count the human minutes per page (notes, fact-check, rewrite, approval) and compare them with the hours you really have. Set the sliders to your own situation: if the gap surprises you, better to find out now than three months into a plan.

Then make one decision from the last number: that is your page count for next month. A plan you can do properly beats a bigger one you finish by skipping the checks.

Try the numbers

Your AI content plan, in human hours

8 pages
90 min
6 h

Hours your plan needs

12 h

Hours you are short

6 h

Pages you can do properly

4 pages

Your own estimate, not a target. If the last number is smaller than the pages you wanted, publish fewer, better pages rather than cutting the human steps.

The AI habit that is a problem even if Google never sees it

At the start we promised one AI habit that causes trouble whatever Google does. Before the answer, make your guess.

Quick quiz

Which of these uses of AI is a problem even on a page Google never shows to anyone?

Pick one. Your first answer is the one that counts.

The same rule covers years of experience, customer numbers, case studies and awards: use AI to tidy real evidence you have permission to use, never to create it. The other habits that turn AI content into a liability:

  • Publishing the first draft. It reads fine, which is the trap: “fine” is what every competitor’s first draft also says.
  • Spinning up pages for every keyword, town or product variant just because it is now cheap.
  • Bulk-rewriting a competitor’s article “in your own words”. Rewording other content without adding value is one of the patterns Google’s spam policies name.
  • Putting “AI” or a made-up persona in the byline instead of a real person who stands behind the page.
  • Pasting customer data or confidential documents into a tool without checking how it stores and uses what you paste.

Score your current AI content process

This checks your process, not any single page. Be honest: the result tells you which one habit to fix first.

Score yourself

How safe is the way you use AI today?

  1. We start from our own notes, not an empty prompt

  2. Every number, name and rule is checked against a source before publishing

  3. Each page includes at least one detail from our own work: a job, a photo, a price, an opinion

  4. A named person reads the whole page and approves it

  5. We only create a page when a real customer question or service sits behind it

  6. We never use AI to write reviews, testimonials or credentials

0 / 12

0 of 6 answered. Answer them all to see your result.

What to do this week

You do not need to delete everything AI ever touched. Start with the pages that matter most and work outwards. If the calculator showed you are short of hours, this list is the better use of them than new pages.

When you have picked your three pages, run each one through the free SEO check linked at the end of this guide. It cannot judge whether your writing is helpful, but it does show whether the title, description and headings, the parts AI tools often write on autopilot, are missing or need attention.

Checklist

Your AI content clean-up

0 of 7 done

Saved on this device only

Questions people ask

Will Google know that I used AI?

Google has not said it tries to detect AI and treat it differently, and its guidance is that it rewards quality however content is made. Ask a better question: would a customer notice that the page says nothing specific? They usually do.

Do I have to tell readers I used AI?

Google suggests disclosing it where readers might reasonably wonder how something was made. For a page you drafted with AI and then checked and rewrote yourself, a clear human author is usually the more useful signal. Some laws and platforms have their own disclosure rules, so check what applies to you.

Can I use AI for product descriptions?

Yes, as long as the facts come from the manufacturer or your own stock data and someone checks them. Hundreds of near-identical descriptions with nothing specific are the risk, so add what you know: fit, real use, what customers ask about. Our guide to product pages that get found and bought lists what a good one includes.

Is it fine to use AI for titles and meta descriptions?

Yes. It is a good use of a tool. Check that each one describes its page accurately and is not the same as its neighbours. The free Google result preview tool on this site shows how a title and description will look in the results before you publish, and our guide to title tags and meta descriptions covers what makes one worth clicking.

My traffic dropped and I used a lot of AI content. Is that why?

Maybe, but do not assume. Check Search Console for a manual action first, then see which pages lost visits and whether a Google update was announced at the time. Our traffic drop guide walks through it calmly, and if there is a manual action, the Google penalties guide covers the recovery.

Everything in this guide was about what your own pages say. Google and AI assistants also build their picture of your business from every other page that mentions you: directories, reviews, old listings, the local press. If those disagree with your site, even well-written pages leave a blurred impression.

That is where the next guide in this series picks up: becoming a known brand to Google and AI. It starts with a simple test you can do in a minute: search your own business name and look at what a new customer would see.

You reached the end

Your summary

This guide has 11 quick questions

Try them to see how much you already know. Your first answer is the one that counts.

Start with the first question

New guides by email when they are published.

Unsubscribe in one click.

What to do next

  1. Open your three most important AI-written pages and fact-check every number, name and price on them.
  2. Add one detail from your own work to each of those pages: a real job, a photo, a price or an honest opinion.
  3. Write a short team rule: AI may draft, a named person checks and approves, AI never writes reviews or credentials.

Check your own site

Run our free site check: most of the technical points above, in under a minute.

Run the free check

AI search

Becoming a known brand to Google and AI: get your facts right everywhere

Search your own business name. If the result shows an old address, a different company or nothing at all, this guide is for you.

26 min readStart reading

See it applied in an illustrative case study

Invented businesses and modelled figures, not client results: how the work in this guide fits into a whole engagement.

See all 89 studies