Skip to content
Get Ranked On TopIllustrative case studySignal plan

A fictional business. The figures are a modelled scenario, not a client result.

Tornasol Tinacos · Water-tank cleaning & plumbing, 20 crews · Guadalajara

How a Guadalajara tank-cleaning firm turned 70 copy-paste city pages into 24 that stay indexed

Guadalajara, Mexico · 8 months · Local services

+158%

organic service requests a month

From above, every tank is a city page. When a page is fixed, its water runs clear.

1The leak

Seventy pages, one page copied seventy times.

Seventy near-identical city pages from a page builder bloated the index, and a chat widget shifted the mobile layout, so service pages kept falling out.

Tornasol’s twenty crews clean tanks and fix plumbing across the whole metro area. A page builder had stamped out a page for every municipality and colonia: same text, same stock photo, only the city name swapped. Google saw seventy near-copies, kept a handful and dropped the rest, and which ones it kept changed from week to week.

On phones, a chat widget loaded late and pushed the whole page down just as people reached for the call button. The service pages that did get indexed scored poorly on layout stability and kept sliding out of the results.

Roof inspection · month 0

  1. 70

    City pages from one template

    Built in an afternoon with a page builder: one block of copy, the city name dropped in five times.

  2. 91%

    Average similarity

    Measured pairwise across all seventy pages. Above 80%, search engines treat pages as duplicates.

  3. 47

    Crawled, not indexed

    Search Console listed 47 city pages as crawled but left out of the index, and the list reshuffled weekly.

  4. 0.38

    Mobile CLS, 75th percentile

    Field data for the service pages. Anything above 0.25 is poor; good is 0.1 or less.

  5. 96 px

    Bar injected after load

    The chat widget inserted a bar at the top of the page about a second after it rendered, with no space reserved.

  6. 3

    Real job photos on the site

    Twenty crews, thousands of jobs a year, and the pages showed the same stock photo of a smiling plumber.

2The duplicate sieve

Compare two city pages. Then decide.

Every pair of city pages goes through the sieve. If two pages are near-copies, there are only two honest fixes: make each one genuinely local, or fold the weaker one into a zone page that deserves to rank.

First page
Second page

First page

/limpieza-de-tinacos-zapopan

Limpieza de tinacos en Zapopan

640 jobs last year

What the page is made of

  • Template copy: 90%
  • Already local: 10%

Similarity

Second page

/limpieza-de-tinacos-el-salto

Limpieza de tinacos en El Salto

12 jobs last year

What the page is made of

  • Template copy: 94%
  • Already local: 6%

Near-duplicate. Google will likely keep one of these and drop the other.El Salto has too few jobs to fill a page of its own: consolidate it.

Differentiate both pages

Not enough work in El Salto to show

Not enough work in El Salto to show

How to use it: pick two cities, then add local proof to both, or consolidate the one with too few jobs. The tank shows the similarity: murky is duplicate, clear is distinct. Modelled data.

3CLS

The jumping chat button

The chat widget arrived a second late and shoved everything down. Reserve its space and nothing moves.

CLS0.38

poor

Good is 0.1 or less

The content was pushed down by 96 px: CLS 0.38, poor.

4The work

Four jobs on the roof.

The engagement ran on our Signal plan: technical SEO that fixes how a site is built, so the pages that deserve to rank can stay in the index.

  1. 01 · Duplicate consolidation

    70 → 24 pages

    Seventy pages through the sieve

    Every pair scored for similarity. Eighteen cities with real demand were rebuilt with crews’ photos, a log of jobs done there and FAQs about local water supply. Fifty-two thin pages were folded into six zone pages with 301 redirects.

  2. 02 · Index bloat cleanup

    24 of 24 indexed

    An index that only holds what counts

    Merged URLs removed from the sitemap, internal links pointed straight at the final pages, page-builder archives and tag pages set to noindex. Crawl budget went to the pages that sell.

  3. 03 · Core Web Vitals (CLS)

    CLS 0.38 → 0.04

    A slot for the chat widget

    The widget now loads into a box of fixed height that is there from the first paint, and only after the page is idle. Fonts got size-adjusted fallbacks so headlines stopped jumping too.

  4. 04 · Structured data

    6 zones · 18 cities

    Telling Google what each page serves

    LocalBusiness and Service structured data with the area each page covers, breadcrumbs from zone to city, and one canonical per page.

5Eight months, tank by tank

The water clears a little every month.

  1. Month 1

    Crawl and sieve

    All seventy city pages crawled and compared pair by pair. Field CLS pulled from real Chrome users.

    Similarity
    91%
    Pages
    70
  2. Month 2

    The widget gets a slot

    Fixed-height slot, deferred load, fallback fonts sized to match. Mobile CLS falls from 0.38 to 0.06.

    Similarity
    84%
    Pages
    58
  3. Month 3

    First consolidation

    Twelve colonia pages with almost no jobs folded into zone pages with 301s. Sitemap trimmed.

    Similarity
    62%
    Pages
    36
  4. Month 4

    Six zone pages

    The last forty thin pages merged. Six zone pages go live with real coverage maps and internal links to each city.

    Similarity
    45%
    Pages
    24
  5. Month 5

    Crews take photos

    Every crew photographs its jobs, with the owner’s permission. Eighteen city pages get their own gallery and job log.

    Similarity
    38%
    Pages
    24
  6. Month 6

    Questions from the street

    FAQs written from real calls: hard water in Tlajomulco, low pressure on the hills of Zapopan, cisterns versus tanks.

    Similarity
    36%
    Pages
    24
  7. Month 7

    Structured data

    LocalBusiness and Service markup with the area each page serves; breadcrumbs from zone to city.

    Similarity
    35%
    Pages
    24
  8. Month 8

    Guardrails

    A rule in the page builder: no new city page until a city has at least a hundred jobs a year to show.

    Similarity
    34%
    Pages
    24

6Inspection at month eight

Fewer pages, all of them clear.

+158%

Organic service requests a month
12031002468MONTH

70 → 24

City pages (all indexed)
7024indexedpages02468MONTH

0.38 → 0.04

Mobile CLS (75th percentile)
good ≤ 0.10.3802468MONTH

91% → 34%

Average city-page similarity
80%91%34%02468MONTH

Modelled scenario for a fictional business — not a client result. Rankings and traffic are never guaranteed; see our Terms.

Zone by zone

City pages and organic service requests per zone, before and after
ZonePages beforePages afterRequests a month
West16530 → 82
East14526 → 70
South15524 → 61
North9314 → 34
Centre10418 → 43
Lakeside628 → 20

Is your index full of copies?

Get a plan like this

We find the pages that compete with each other and the code that makes your layout jump, then fix both.

← Back to all case studies