26 of 36
26 of the 36 category pages were named after in-house collections (Ballard, Alki, Fremont) that nobody searches for; 19 earned no impressions in a year. The other ten were bare product types: Pulls, Knobs, Hinges.
Entry 1 of 4
A fictional business. The figures are a modelled scenario, not a client result.
Hemlock & Hinge
8,000-SKU cabinet hardware store · Seattle
Ecommerce case notes · Seattle · North America
+64% organic revenue once every search had its own page
12 months · North America · Commerce SEO plan
01The challenge
Categories were named after in-house collections, not the finishes and centre-to-centre sizes shoppers type, so 8,000 SKUs ranked for nothing specific.
Hemlock & Hinge sells 8,000 pulls, knobs and hinges to renovators and cabinet makers across the US. Its catalogue was organised the way the warehouse thought: by in-house collections and part numbers. Shoppers think in finishes and hole spacing. They measure the old pull, type “128mm” or “3 inch”, add “matte black”, and buy from whoever has a page for exactly that. Hemlock & Hinge had the products, but no page that said so.
Fig. 2 · One pull, two vocabularies
No page on the site was cut for that search, so Google sent it to competitors who had a matte-black page and a 128 mm page.
02Diagnosis
26 of 36
26 of the 36 category pages were named after in-house collections (Ballard, Alki, Fremont) that nobody searches for; 19 earned no impressions in a year. The other ten were bare product types: Pulls, Knobs, Hinges.
Entry 1 of 4
185,964
Seven filters (finish, size, material, style, collection, price, sort) combined freely into 185,964 crawlable parameter URLs, all with the same title. Googlebot spent 78% of its requests there.
Entry 2 of 4
71%
41,000 queries mapped to the catalogue: 71% named a finish or a centre-to-centre size. Hinge searches named a mechanism (soft-close, concealed, overlay) the site never used as a page.
Entry 3 of 4
8,000 SKUs
Titles were part numbers. Finish and size lived only in a variant dropdown, so Google saw one page per pull, no Product schema, and 1,400 near-duplicates that differed only by finish.
Entry 4 of 4
03The strategy
Built on our Commerce SEO plan: ecommerce SEO for catalogues where the category tree, the filters and the product data decide what can rank.
Cut 1
A new tree cut the way people search: product type first, then finish, centre-to-centre size and hinge type. Finish × size pages exist only where search volume proved demand: 90 of 612 possible. The 26 collection pages were 301-redirected to the finish pages that now hold their products.
Cut 2
Filters stayed for shoppers but left the index. Parameter URLs carry a canonical to their category, sort and price are noindex, and only the 190 combinations with real demand became static, linkable paths. 185,964 crawlable filter URLs fell to none.
Cut 3
One ProductGroup per pull, every finish and size a variant with its own GTIN, price and stock, declared through variesBy. Titles are now built from attributes, such as Matte Black Bar Pull, 128 mm (5 in), so each variant can match the search that names it.
Cut 4
Each category page got 120–200 words that answer the real question (which spacing suits a 24-inch drawer, which finishes match), plus a size guide, a finish comparison and links from every product back up to its finish and size pages.
04The dovetail jig
Each tail is a cluster of real searches. Each pin is a kind of category page. Switch the cuts on and off: a tail with no socket holds the boards apart, and a cut that serves no search leaves a gap in the joint.
Keyword-led cuts
Legacy cuts
8 searches have no socket, so the boards won’t close.
matte black cabinet pulls14,800 / mo
Falls back to /collections/ballard/
3 inch drawer pulls9,900 / mo
Falls back to /pulls/?size=76
128mm cabinet pulls6,600 / mo
Falls back to /pulls/?size=128&sort=new
brushed brass pulls 128mm2,400 / mo
Falls back to /collections/alki/
oil rubbed bronze cabinet knobs5,400 / mo
Falls back to /collections/fremont/
soft close cabinet hinges12,100 / mo
Falls back to /hinges/
concealed hinges for frameless cabinets4,400 / mo
Falls back to /hinges/?type=euro&page=3
satin nickel cup pulls2,900 / mo
Falls back to /collections/ballard/?page=2
Volumes are modelled US monthly searches. Collections and filters are the old store’s cuts; switch them off and the finish, size and hinge pages take their place.
05Month by month
Months 1–2
41,000 queries mapped to 8,000 SKUs, a crawl of 194,000 URLs, twelve weeks of server logs and revenue per category from order data.
Months 3–4
The new tree drawn on paper first: type, finish, size, hinge type. 90 finish × size pages chosen from 612 on search volume; a 301 map for 26 collections.
Month 5
Canonical and noindex rules for filters, sort and price. Googlebot’s share on parameter URLs fell from 74% to 41% in four weeks.
Months 6–8
200 category pages launched, ProductGroup schema on 8,000 SKUs, titles rebuilt from attributes in batches, one product type at a time.
Months 9–12
Category copy, size guides and finish comparisons; links from products up to their finish and size pages; merchant listings checked monthly.
06Results
Organic revenue (month 12)
+64%
1,180 → 1,935 organic orders / month
Non-brand organic clicks / month
21,400 → 46,900
+119% in twelve months
Category pages in the top 10
3 → 146
146 of 200 new category pages
Indexable URLs
194,000 → 8,200
Filters out of the index; crawl back on products and categories
Modelled scenario for a fictional business — not a client result. Rankings and traffic are never guaranteed; see our Terms.
| Search | Category page | Volume / mo | Before | Month 12 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| matte black cabinet pulls | /pulls/matte-black/ | 14,800 | #47 | #4 |
| 3 inch drawer pulls | /pulls/3-inch-76mm/ | 9,900 | 100+ | #6 |
| 128mm cabinet pulls | /pulls/128mm-5-inch/ | 6,600 | #62 | #3 |
| brushed brass pulls 128mm | /pulls/brushed-brass/128mm/ | 2,400 | 100+ | #2 |
| oil rubbed bronze cabinet knobs | /knobs/oil-rubbed-bronze/ | 5,400 | #38 | #5 |
| soft close cabinet hinges | /hinges/soft-close/ | 12,100 | #29 | #7 |
| concealed hinges for frameless cabinets | /hinges/concealed-frameless/ | 4,400 | 100+ | #3 |
| satin nickel cup pulls | /cup-pulls/satin-nickel/ | 2,900 | #54 | #2 |
Modelled Google US positions and monthly volumes; 100+ means outside the first hundred results. Queries shown as shoppers type them.
Running a catalogue that ranks for nothing specific? Start with the Commerce SEO plan, or tell us how your shoppers search.