9,240
9,240 retired listings still answered 200 OK, and Search Console had flagged 6,420 of them as soft 404s. Each looked like a thin duplicate: the same sold banner, the same footer, no price, no photos.
Box 1 of 4
A fictional business. The figures are a modelled scenario, not a client result.
Estiada HomesThessaloniki, Greece
New listings indexed in 6 hours, not 19 days
Real estate agency, 2 offices, 1,800 active listings · Thessaloniki
9 months · Europe · Signal plan
Every key is a listing URL. Row by row, the soft 404s give way to clean status codes.
01The challenge
Sold listings still answered 200 with “no longer available”: thousands of soft 404s. Filter crawl traps kept new homes waiting weeks to be indexed.
Estiada sells and lets homes across Thessaloniki from two offices, and its listings move fast: a good two-bedroom in Kalamaria can be under offer within a week. The website, though, never let a listing leave. Sold, withdrawn and expired homes kept their pages, their 200 status and a small banner saying “no longer available”. Meanwhile every filter on the search page (price, size, sort order, map area) produced another crawlable URL. Googlebot spent its visits in the archive and the filter maze, and a fresh listing could wait three weeks to show up in search, long after the keenest buyers had moved on.
What Google was served
HTTP/1.1 200 OKestiadahomes.example/listings/3611/
3-bedroom flat · Kalamaria · 96 m²
€245,000
This property has been sold. Browse similar homes.
02Diagnosis
9,240
9,240 retired listings still answered 200 OK, and Search Console had flagged 6,420 of them as soft 404s. Each looked like a thin duplicate: the same sold banner, the same footer, no price, no photos.
Box 1 of 4
1.4M
Price, size, sort and map filters were plain links that combined freely: about 1.4 million crawlable URLs for 1,800 homes, with pagination stacked on top that never ran out.
Box 2 of 4
68%
Eight weeks of server logs: 68% of Googlebot requests went to filter URLs and 19% to retired listings. The live listings, the pages that earn the agency money, got 9%.
Box 3 of 4
19 days
A new listing took a median 19 days to reach the index, and only 61% of live listings were indexed at all. Details loaded client-side from an API, and the sitemap was rebuilt weekly with one lastmod for every URL.
Box 4 of 4
03The strategy
Built on our Signal plan: the technical engagement for sites where status codes, crawl paths and rendering decide what Google sees.
One rule set, run nightly from the agency's CRM. Live and under-offer homes answer 200. When a sold home is relisted, or a near-identical flat in the same building is live, the old URL 301s to it: 2,180 redirects. Everything else answers 410 Gone, on a page that still shows people the area's live homes: 7,060 URLs.
312 area-by-type and area-by-bedroom combinations became static, indexable hub pages with their own copy. Price, size, sort and map filters stopped being links, their parameter patterns were disallowed in robots.txt, and every remaining variant canonicalises to its hub.
Listing pages now render on the server, so price, photos and description are in the first HTML. A new-listings sitemap refreshes every 15 minutes with a true lastmod, IndexNow notifies Bing, and each area hub links to “new this week” homes within minutes of publishing.
Googlebot logs ingested daily: first-crawl time for every new listing, hits on 410s tapering off, and an alert the moment any filter pattern gets crawled again. A weekly report shows time to index per office.
04Ring the bells
Each bell is a listing URL, picked roughly in proportion to the 11,040 listing URLs Google knew about. Switch between before and after the fix, then ring.
Nº 3,054
Soft 404
Arrow keys move between bells
Bell Nº 3,054 · Ladadika
Sold, then the same flat came back on the market as Nº 4,512.
Before the fix
HTTP/1.1 200 OK
Soft 404
Still 200 with a “no longer available” banner. Google reported a soft 404 and dropped the page.
After the fix
HTTP/1.1 301 Moved Permanently
Location: /listings/4512/
301 to a similar listing
Redirects once to Nº 4,512, so the old page's links and history now help the live listing.
05Month by month
Residents' board
Month 1Audit
Full crawl, eight weeks of logs, the Search Console soft-404 export and a CRM extract of every listing ever published.
Months 2–3Lifecycle rules
A status for every listing state, agreed with both offices; the similar-flat rule tested on 500 sold homes; 301s and 410s shipped in month 3.
Month 4Close the traps
312 hub pages launched, filter links replaced, robots.txt patterns and canonicals live. Googlebot's share on filter URLs fell from 66% to 12% within the month.
Month 5Fresh lane
Server-rendered listing pages, the 15-minute sitemap, IndexNow and “new this week” blocks on every hub.
Months 6–9Watch and tune
Daily log checks, a weekly time-to-index report per office, and hub copy written for the 40 busiest area pages.
06Results
Median time to index a new listing
19 days → 6 h
Median for new listings in month 9, down from 19 days in month 1
Soft 404s in Search Console
6,420 → 31
Search Console, page indexing report
Googlebot requests to filter URLs
68% → 4%
Share of Googlebot requests, from server logs
Organic viewing requests a month
+41%
210 → 296 organic viewing requests a month
Modelled scenario for a fictional business — not a client result. Rankings and traffic are never guaranteed; see our Terms.
| Answer | Before | Month 9 |
|---|---|---|
| 200 · live listing | 1,800 | 1,800 |
| Soft 404 | 9,240 | 31 |
| 301 to a similar listing | 0 | 2,180 |
| 410 Gone | 0 | 7,060 |
Before the fix all 9,240 retired pages behaved as soft 404s, and Search Console had flagged 6,420 of them; 31 remain, mostly homes sold in the past week. Live listings in the index: 61% → 97%.
Listings, job ads, events, stock that sells out: if your pages expire, the Signal plan gives each one the right status code and gets the new ones indexed fast.