No redirect
900
The guide archive never appeared in either sitemap, so it never reached the redirect map. Tax guides returned 404, with 1,240 external links still pointing at them.
Card 1 of 4
A fictional business. The figures are a modelled scenario, not a client result.
Case file · after a merger
Doppio Commercialisti · Accounting & tax-advisory firm, 3 offices · Turin
+131% organic leads after the redirect rebuild
11 months · Europe · Signal plan · Redirect mapping · Chain flattening · Soft-404 triage · Canonical consolidation
AThe challenge
A merger left two domains. The move to one site dropped the redirects for 900 old guide pages, created chains and soft 404s, and organic leads fell by half.
Two Turin practices merged into one firm of 50 people across three offices. Their websites were folded into a new domain over a weekend: the redirect map was generated from the XML sitemaps, and neither sitemap listed the guide archive that brought in most of the enquiries. Eight months later Search Console was full of errors and the phones were quieter.
↓ moved in one weekend to ↓
Organic leads a month
120
before the merger
58
eight months after the move
BDiagnosis
A crawl of both old domains, rebuilt from server logs, Search Console exports, backlink data and the two old CMS databases. Each of the 2,140 old URLs was punched on four holes.
No redirect
900
The guide archive never appeared in either sitemap, so it never reached the redirect map. Tax guides returned 404, with 1,240 external links still pointing at them.
Card 1 of 4
Redirect chain
410
http → https → www → old host → new site: up to 5 hops, 3.4 on average. Every hop cost crawl budget, and a quarter of the chains ended on the wrong page.
Card 2 of 4
Soft 404
260
Old service and office pages were sent wholesale to the new homepage. Google treated them as soft 404s and dropped the rankings they had held.
Card 3 of 4
Canonical conflict
180
Both firms had written guides on the same topics. The duplicates named each other as canonical, or an old-domain URL that redirected, so Google picked neither.
Card 4 of 4
38% of Googlebot requests in the logs went to URLs that were dead, redirecting or duplicated.
CThe strategy
Built on our Signal plan: the technical engagement for sites where crawling, redirects and architecture decide the outcome.
The map rebuilt from every source, not just the sitemaps: logs, Search Console, backlinks and both CMS databases. 2,140 old URLs, each matched by hand or by rule to the closest new page and given a single 301.
All rules moved to the edge and rewritten to point straight at the final URL. http, www and old-host variants now resolve in one hop, and internal links point at final URLs only.
No more wholesale redirects to the homepage. Each soft 404 got a real destination, rebuilt where needed, or an honest 410 when the topic was obsolete.
Duplicate guides merged topic by topic into one stronger page. Self-referencing canonicals everywhere, and XML sitemaps that list final URLs only.
DNeedle sort
Each card is an old URL from the two merged domains; each notch along its top edge is a fault. Choose a hole, then switch the redirect map from the one that shipped to the one we rebuilt.
Push the needle through a hole
The drawer is closed
Choose a hole above. In a real edge-notched index the needle goes through the whole deck at once, and the notched cards drop.
before the merger: 120
0 of 24 cards fell out
/guide/regime-forfettario-2023
404 · no redirect
/servizi/contabilita-ordinaria
4 hops
/guide/730-precompilato-scadenze
404 · no redirect
/servizi/dichiarazione-redditi
→ homepage · soft 404
/guide/imu-seconda-casa-torino
404 · no redirect
/servizi/revisione-legale
301 · one hop
/guide/cedolare-secca
canonical → duplicate
/guide/partita-iva-apertura
404 · no redirect
/servizi/paghe-e-contributi
3 hops
/guide/fattura-elettronica-errori
404 · no redirect
/studi/torino-centro
301 · one hop
/servizi/crisi-impresa
→ homepage · soft 404
/guide/successione-dichiarazione
404 · no redirect
/chi-siamo/team
3 hops
/guide/bonus-edilizi-cessione
404 · no redirect
/blog/cedolare-secca-affitti
canonical → duplicate
/guide/isee-2024
5 hops
/guide/tfr-calcolo
301 · one hop
/guide/ravvedimento-operoso-calcolo
404 · no redirect
/contatti/moncalieri
→ homepage · soft 404
/blog/f24-compensazione
404 · no redirect
/servizi/consulenza-societaria
3 hops
/blog/rottamazione-quater
301 · one hop
/blog/srl-semplificata-costi
404 · no redirect
Needle out. Every card is back in the drawer.
EMonth by month
Month 1
Both old domains crawled from logs, Search Console exports, backlink data and the old CMS databases: 2,140 URLs punched on four holes.
Months 2–3
Every old URL matched to its closest new page, 140 duplicate guide pairs lined up for merging, the map tested against a staging crawl.
Month 4
The new map live at the edge in one release: one hop for every URL, chains gone, internal links updated.
Months 5–7
Soft 404s given real destinations, duplicate guides merged, canonicals and sitemaps cleaned; the recrawl watched in the logs every day.
Months 8–11
Tax-season guides refreshed ahead of the 730 and IMU deadlines, pages for all three offices, internal links from guides to services.
FResults
Organic leads / month
58 → 134
58 → 134 a month · 120 before the merger
Lost guide pages redirected
900
One hop each, to the closest new guide
Redirect chains
410 → 0
Up to 5 hops before, one after
Top-10 keywords
150 → 410
380 before the merger
Modelled scenario for a fictional business — not a client result. Rankings and traffic are never guaranteed; see our Terms.
| Query | Month 1 | Month 11 |
|---|---|---|
| commercialista torino | #18 | #7 |
| regime forfettario requisiti | — | #3 |
| imu seconda casa torino | — | #2 |
| aprire partita iva costi | #41 | #6 |
| commercialista moncalieri | #12 | #2 |
| cedolare secca come funziona | #27 | #5 |
| dichiarazione di successione documenti | — | #4 |
— = not in the top 100. Positions are modelled, checked from one Turin location.
Merging firms, moving domains or cleaning up after a migration that went wrong? Start with the Signal plan, or tell us what you are moving.